Showing posts with label DCnU Supergirl 7. Show all posts
Showing posts with label DCnU Supergirl 7. Show all posts
Thursday, April 12, 2012
Sales Review: March 2012
Comics finally took a down turn in sales in March overall and DC saw Marvel slip back into the top 10 after a giddy two months of the New 52 equaling the top 10. As always, my sales numbers come from ICv2, a great site for comics news and market analysis. Here is the link to March's numbers:http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/22625.html
The mega-event of Avengers vs. XMen shook up the top spots but it was great to see Action Comics and Superman stay in the top 10, especially given the mini-shake-up with the creative direction on the Superman title.
And while the top titles all stuck around the top, I do wonder if the bottom of the 52 has simply bottomed out.
As for Supergirl, I think the title has basically found it's level in the 50's in rank and around 30K+ in sales.
Supergirl #7, the conclusion of the first arc sold 33,337, down a slim 4% from the prior month's sales. I think the book has been on the rise since the somewhat slow first couple of issues. And this issue, in particular, helped define the character of Kara moving forward. Hopefully those of us here have decided to stay here.
I do wonder if the four year plan to reveal all the aspects of Supergirl's origins may be too slow of a boil for the casual fan. Will people be willing to jump on board in the middle of a mystery?
Lastly, while Mahmud Asrar's art has been simply spectacular, it will be interesting to see if next month's George Perez issue will lead to a bump in sales.
Still, the title remains very healthy in sales.
As for the bottom of the DCnU, my original underdog title to promote, Sterling Gates' Hawk and Dove, has already been cancelled.
So let's look at Legion Lost, which may not be on long for this Earth.
Legion Lost #7 was Tom DeFalco's first issue as writer and the issue had a different feel to it. There was no narrator the way there was with Fabien Nicieza. A new Earth sidekick joined the team. There was a sort of PSA 'don't text and drive' storyline, and the Hypertaxis storyline was pushed a bit into the background.
But the title is suffering a bit, selling only 16,393. It doesn't look like the comic market can sustain 2 Legion books (even the main title is selling in the low 20K's). If this title does get cancelled, DC better give Pete Woods a new title right away. His stuff has been so slick here.
Labels:
DCnU Supergirl 7,
Legion Lost,
Mahmud Asrar,
Michael Green,
Mike Johnson,
sales
Saturday, March 24, 2012
Review: Supergirl #7
Supergirl #7 came out this week and marked the end of the book's first run, a sort of semi-origin story. I say semi-origin because we don't have all the details yet. Writers Michael Green and Mike Johnson said all along that Kara's origin was going to be a slow boil with more and more details on how she got to Earth being revealed. But this arc accomplished what it needed to. It got Supergirl to Earth and started on the path of heroism.
We only know the broadest strokes of her origin. She was sent to Earth via a pod from Argo City which initially survived the explosion of Krypton. But outside of that we only have some threads and some mysteries. I have to say I have puzzled over these details a lot and have some thoughts. But like Kara, I am flying a bit blind.
But for me, this issue again cemented the fact that the creative team is going to have Supergirl be the sort hero she ought to be. I know I am beating a dead horse here but the initial publicity pieces and the current Supergirl character page on the DC website play up Kara as being an out of control, disaffected, isolated, angry young woman. If this issue doesn't squelch that completely, I don't know what will. I can't thank the creators enough for that.
And, as always, Mahmud Asrar really delivers a completely phenomenal issue full of insane action drawn both big and small. This is a 20 page brawl, no doubt, but with wonderful characterization slid between the punches.
The issue starts with Reign giving some exposition about the origin of the Worldkillers. They were embryos from other planets which were stolen by Kryptonian scientists and experimented on. These manipulations were designed to strengthen and embolden these creatures. And they were named Worldkillers after Kryptonian mythological creatures.
They awaken from their suspended animation on the dying city of Argo, learned what they could there, and have been on the hunt for their own origins since then. It is close enought to Kara's story to make me pause. But more on that later.
Now one thing that remains fuzzy about a lot of Supergirl's origins is the timeline of key events. For example, when was Supergirl rocketed? From Argo before or after the destruction of Krypton? Here, I wonder when did these experiments begin? On the whole Krypton? Or initiated when Argo was shaken free?
My gut tells me this began before Krypton exploded. And these sort of experiments jibe with prior versions of Krypton where genetic manipulation was widespread.
Lastly, where is Zor-El in all this? Was he part of these experiments? Was it the Worldkillers that he wanted to tell Kara about in his end message before he was shot down? Hmmm...
But this story is in the background of the battle happening on in the city. Supergirl is fighting the four Worldkillers and barely holding her own.
The four Killers seem like a sort of slanted Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse.
Reign is the tactical leader, like Death who led the horsemen.
Deimax deals in mass terrain destruction like War.
Perrilus deals in virus generation and population extinction like plague.
And Flower of Heaven is a blaster who specializes in planetary systems overload? Like famine? Stripping the land of its fertility?
Okay, it isn't neat and clean. But that was my first thought.
We also get another look at Supergirl's unique power. It seems female Kryptonians can do some sort of solar flare power. Great panel here.
The fight spills through the city and Supergirl realizes she needs to take the fight into the air because there are 'too many innocents' around. Supergirl already cares about the people of Earth.
The city is encased in a force field which makes Supergirl wonder how the Worldkillers got hold of Zor-El's technology. Now sure, they are in a ship probably from Krypton which may be equipped with the ability. But that seems too easy. What if the Worldkillers were responsible somehow for the field which saved Argo? What if they saved the city while being kept in stasis? And is that what Zor-El wanted to tell Kara? The truth behind how he saved Argo.
Hmmm.
Amazed that Supergirl seems to be able to hold her own, Reign offers Supergirl a place within the group. It seems odd that Supergirl has lasted this long since only Worldkillers can defeat other world killers. Hmmm ...
Without a connection to the people of Earth, it is possible Supergirl could have accepted the offer. But instead Supergirl shows she is not a killer, shouting she is stubborn, and leveling Reign. Now being stubborn is something I can deal with in a new hero. And this was just too great a splash not to share.
One editing note: when Reign says only Worldkillers can defeat Worldkillers, it is written that only Wordkillers can defeat Wordkillers. Typos like that, especially in a key line in the script, distract.
Now there are lots of great panels in this issue. But this one might ... might ... be my favorite. Probably my second favorite.
Supergirl says she won't let anyone else be hurt. She'll die before she let's that happen. She has something to save. That is a sort of 'turn the corner' panel in characterization. This Kara is a hero, willing to die to save an alien race she doesn't know at all.
And those words just wonderfully complement the art which show that death is a possibility and bloody knuckles are a certainty. The angle is looking up on the fierce Worldkillers, tooth an claw bared. The only thing we see of the protagonist is her clenched fist, a sign of defiance against the odds. Fantastic!
But only Worldkillers can defeat Worldkillers. So ingeniously, Kara grabs the poison stingers of Perrilus and impales Deimax. It shows Supergirl is intelligent and battle savvy and gutsy.
With one of her troops down and potentially dying, Reign decides to retreat.
But first, an end speech. The Worldkillers will be back and, as they are still evolving, they will be stronger. Hmmm...
And there was a 5th tube in that deserted lab on Argo. Who is the fifth Worldkiller?
Well, all these 'hmmms' make me wonder if it's Supergirl. She could stand toe to toe with Worldkillers, something only Worldkillers can do. She can do unique things - like a solar flare - that other powered Kryptonians can't, as if she was genetically enhanced or evolved. She has no recollection of the destruction of Krypton or the plight of Argo City ... maybe because she was in stasis in a tube. And maybe that is what Zor-El wanted to tell her ... the truth about her ... that she was experimented on.
As an old time fan, I don't want Kara to have been experimented on by her father, to be a 'Worldkiller'. But we'll see how this plays out.
This is my favorite panel, an ending splash page and great capstone for this arc.
The Worldkillers are gone, the dome has been lifted, and a tired Supergirl sports a sort of satisfied and incredulous look on her face. She says for once she won. Maybe she underestimates herself and needs to become confident along the hero's journey. And what a great natural pose by Asrar here. You can feel her fatigue and happiness. And no needless cheesecake.
That's Supergirl!
The title 'Graduation Day' makes me think that Kara will view this battle as the 'trial' she was supposed to go through on Krypton, that she feels she has earned her uniform now.
So we have learned more about Argo and Krypton. We have a lot of puzzle pieces that need to merge into a coherent history. And we have a Supergirl risking her life to aid others. Not one 'Hell on Wheels', disaffected panel here! And that makes me a happy fan.
Overall grade: A/B+
Labels:
DCnU Supergirl 7,
Mahmud Asrar,
Michael Green,
Mike Johnson,
review,
Supergirl
Friday, December 23, 2011
March 2012 Solicits
The DC solicits for next March are up. Here are the Super family related books as well as a couple of surprises.
First off, this is a great cover. The angle looking up at Supergirl just adds to the heroic feeling of her. It also helps that she seems to be shielding that child behind her, protecting him. I guess Supergirl has some affection for humanity. But it also works because while we are looking at from the angle of the villains, we still see their faces projected on the jumbotrons. And since they are shown on big screens behind her, it heels as though they are towering over her. Just a superb layout.
But moreover, I had assumed that 'world killers' were some sort of weapon, a doomsday bomb of some sort. But it is clear that Worldkillers are beings. Could they be linked to Doomsday?
This is a very good solicit.
Another great cover with Superman looking into the bottled Metropolis. Very nice. It also seems to work because the citizens of Metropolis are seen in the midground, adding to the feeling of smallness. And what about the creepy Brainiac spiders everywhere. I guess they have to keep the populace in line?
How the heck is this young Superman going to save this city? And more Steel! I am loving this book.
So this is the beginning of the new creative team with Jurgens and Giffen taking over the book. I hope that they bring back some of the magic of Jurgens 90s stuff, a time when Superman was the top hero of the DCU and wasn't dealing with people not trusting him, wasn't wallowing in his own angst. Let's make Superman a hero, beloved by the people, and successful in thwarting evil.
I don't know much about Helspont as a villain, if he is new or not.
Another good cover if only for the major inclusion of Rose on the cover! She is a great character. But last issue's cover was Superboy fighting Supergirl. This cover is Superboy fighting Rose. Hope this book doesn't derail to 'Who will Superboy fight this month?'
As I have said before, this book is the biggest surprise for me in the DCnU. I have enjoyed it a lot!
This is a complete bummer. I loved Tiny Titans. The Supergirls ... all of them, ranging from 8-12 ... loved Tiny Titans. It is sad to see this book go. I hope that Supergirl and all her Super-pets get one last moment to shine here!
And at least Superman Family Adventures is around the corner.
And for an old timer like me, I am seriously thinking about getting this trade celebrating the Fortress in all its incarnations. I can only assume this means that a new Fortress will happen in the DCnU. Nice old school cover here, if this is what they are going to use.
And that is a veritable who's who of creators all in one place!
This month the first trades for the DCnU titles were solicited. No Supergirl trade was listed.
SUPERGIRL #7
Written by MICHAEL GREEN and MIKE JOHNSON
Art and cover by MAHMUD ASRAR
It’s Supergirl versus the Worldkillers! But who are they, and where did they come from? What is their connection to Krypton? More important, can the Girl of Steel stop them before they make good on their names and destroy Earth?
First off, this is a great cover. The angle looking up at Supergirl just adds to the heroic feeling of her. It also helps that she seems to be shielding that child behind her, protecting him. I guess Supergirl has some affection for humanity. But it also works because while we are looking at from the angle of the villains, we still see their faces projected on the jumbotrons. And since they are shown on big screens behind her, it heels as though they are towering over her. Just a superb layout.
But moreover, I had assumed that 'world killers' were some sort of weapon, a doomsday bomb of some sort. But it is clear that Worldkillers are beings. Could they be linked to Doomsday?
This is a very good solicit.
ACTION COMICS #7
Written by GRANT MORRISON
Backup story written by SHOLLY FISCH
Art by RAGS MORALES and RICK BRYANT
Backup story art by BRAD WALKER
Cover by RAGS MORALES
Metropolis has been captured! To save it, Superman must push the limits of his nascent powers as never before! Aboard the ship that has the city captive, The Man of Steel finds an important tool that may help him defeat Metal-zero and his boss!
And as Superman fights foes in the sky, Steel must do what he can to protect those still in danger on the ground in a backup story by Sholly Fisch and Brad Walker!
Another great cover with Superman looking into the bottled Metropolis. Very nice. It also seems to work because the citizens of Metropolis are seen in the midground, adding to the feeling of smallness. And what about the creepy Brainiac spiders everywhere. I guess they have to keep the populace in line?
How the heck is this young Superman going to save this city? And more Steel! I am loving this book.
SUPERMAN #7
Written by KEITH GIFFEN and DAN JURGENS
Art by DAN JURGENS and JESUS MERINO
Cover by IVAN REIS and JOE PRADO
The start of an insanely epic arc from the new writing team of Keith Giffen and Dan Jurgens! New love interests, new roommates, and a new foe: the wicked Helspont! What does this monster want with Superman, and how does it all connect to the Daemonites?
So this is the beginning of the new creative team with Jurgens and Giffen taking over the book. I hope that they bring back some of the magic of Jurgens 90s stuff, a time when Superman was the top hero of the DCU and wasn't dealing with people not trusting him, wasn't wallowing in his own angst. Let's make Superman a hero, beloved by the people, and successful in thwarting evil.
I don't know much about Helspont as a villain, if he is new or not.
SUPERBOY #7
Written by SCOTT LOBDELL
Art by R.B. SILVA and ROB LEAN
Cover by SHANE DAVIS
Superboy’s come back to N.O.W.H.E.R.E. with vengeance on his mind – but Rose Wilson is waiting for him. Right from the start, she was the one meant to bring him down when he went out of control – and this fight is going to be out of control! What can one woman with swords do against the most powerful teenager in the world? You – and Superboy – will be very surprised indeed!
Another good cover if only for the major inclusion of Rose on the cover! She is a great character. But last issue's cover was Superboy fighting Supergirl. This cover is Superboy fighting Rose. Hope this book doesn't derail to 'Who will Superboy fight this month?'
As I have said before, this book is the biggest surprise for me in the DCnU. I have enjoyed it a lot!
TINY TITANS #50
Written by ART BALTAZAR and FRANCO
Art and cover by ART BALTAZAR
FINAL ISSUE
In this awesome 50th issue, questions are answered! Mysteries are solved! The Tiny Titans may be one step closer to becoming Super Heroes! This issue may change your life! Plus, it’s highly recommended by Franco’s mom!
This is a complete bummer. I loved Tiny Titans. The Supergirls ... all of them, ranging from 8-12 ... loved Tiny Titans. It is sad to see this book go. I hope that Supergirl and all her Super-pets get one last moment to shine here!
And at least Superman Family Adventures is around the corner.
SUPERMAN: SECRETS OF THE FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE TP
Written by JERRY SIEGEL, JERRY COLEMAN, ROY THOMAS, JERRY ORDWAY, GEORGE PEREZ, ROGER STERN, MARK SCHULTZ, GEOFF JOHNS and RICHARD DONNER
Art by JOHN SIKELA, WAYNE BORING, ROSS ANDRU, MIKE MIGNOLA, CURT SWAN, DOUG MAHNKE, PHIL JIMENEZ and others
Cover by ROSS ANDRU and DICK GIORDANO
Don’t miss these tales of Superman’s Fortress of Solitude! They’re collected here for the first time from SUPERMAN #17, ACTION COMICS #241 and 261, ACTION COMICS ANNUAL #2 and #10, SUPERMAN: THE MAN OF STEEL #100, and the hard-to-find DC SPECIAL SERIES #26, previously available in tabloid format!
And for an old timer like me, I am seriously thinking about getting this trade celebrating the Fortress in all its incarnations. I can only assume this means that a new Fortress will happen in the DCnU. Nice old school cover here, if this is what they are going to use.
And that is a veritable who's who of creators all in one place!
This month the first trades for the DCnU titles were solicited. No Supergirl trade was listed.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



















