Showing posts with label Supergirl 51. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Supergirl 51. Show all posts

Thursday, April 15, 2010

Sales Review: March 2010

The sales numbers for March came out last week and, as usual, ICv2 does a great job breaking down the numbers. Here is the link to the top 300 comics of last month: http://www.icv2.com/articles/news/17243.html. What better day to review sales than on Tax Day here in America.

Each month I review the Supergirl title sales here and it seems like I am reporting on soil erosion. It has felt like sales numbers on all the Super-titles have slowly crept down over the last year or so.

That said, I was curious to see where sales for Supergirl #51 would fall. Certainly it had a strong lead-in with last month's anniversary issue. This also was an early chapter in Last Stand which has started strongly.

Would sales be up?


Well, Supergirl #51 sold 29,845 units, which was down 11% from the 33,338 units that the Turner cover/variant cover/Helen Slater fueled Supergirl #50 sold.

But I think everyone, including me, expected a slip in sales from that special anniversary issue. The question in my mind was always 'how much will sales drop?'

So a better gauge of sales might be to look back at Supergirl #49's sales which were around 27,728. So the title gained 2,000 readers since that issue. Maybe Last Stand helps. Or maybe some people who sampled the title with the fiftieth issue liked what they read and stuck around. Either way, I look at 30,000 in sales as being 'healthy' in this market and we are there. The product is of such high quality too.

As a side note, this is the first time that I can remember since I began these sales reviews that Supergirl outsold Action Comics. Do you think it is time for Superman to return to his titles?

And how were the sales of R.E.B.E.L.S. #14, which finished the Starro storyline back in March?



It sold 11,362. The book continues to sell around 11,000. (R.E.B.E.L.S. #13 sold 11, 836.) Sales are remarkably stable for this title. Outside the Blackest Night crossovers, this seems to be its level.

The R.E.B.E.L.S. characters are crossing over in Last Stand giving them some added exposure. The Starro storyline is over so this is something of a jumping on point for new readers. And next month the book adds an established draw in the character of Starfire.

I'll be interested to see what R.E.B.E.L.S. sales will be next month. Will those waiting for the Starro story to end jump ship? Will Starfire bring readers in? Or will the same 11,000 diehard fans keep buying this nifty little underappreciated title?

Saturday, March 20, 2010

Review: Supergirl #51

If the first two parts of 'Last Stand of New Krypton' are any indication, I am going to be very happy with it.

Supergirl #51 came out this week and marked the second part of the Last Stand story arc. It definitely felt like a second chapter, like it flowed straight from Superman:Last Stand of New Krypton #1. But it also maintained a definite Supergirl focus. And it continued to move the overall story forward while maintaining some small moments that gives the plot some human gravitas.

I was hoping that the Last Stand issues would begin a renumbering in the S-shield on the covers. While I haven't always felt that the cover numbering has added much, here I think it would have. This should be #2 in this Last Stand arc ... not #33 of the bigger arc.

But that is a quibble when you look at the content of the issue.


I have talked about the small moments in comics before and this issue starts out with a good one.

A couple of Kryptonian teachers are having a field trip away from Kandor while Brainiac attacks. The teachers, scared of Brainiac themselves, are hopeful that their distance from the city will keep them unnoticed. They also try to keep the children from looking at the fiery carnage raining down on the city.

Unfortunately when you have super-hearing, nothing is ever too far away. As is usual, Jamal Igle does a great job on the art here. The expression on this young Kryptonian's face says it all ... the sheer terror she is feeling as the planet's boogey man comes back to reclaim his prize.

Just like in the first issue, big moments get big art. Here is a great double page spread of Supergirl and Mon-El wading into battle with the Brainiac probes.

You would think super-powered beings would laugh at an attack from Terminators, but these robots are built for Kryptonian combat. And we see quite clearly the damage they can do to the Kandorians with their red sun blasts. It is a pretty brutal display of the citizens being perforated and eviscerated by the drones.

Again, it is refreshing to see Supergirl so strong and brave as she battles. This isn't the frightened girl on Argo whose best friend was kidnapped by Brainiac. This is a mature young woman defending her people.

During the fight, Mon-El gets a telepathic overload from Tellus. Suddenly Mon-El is not only aware that the Legion is being arrested by Zod, he also knows that Superman has been captured by Brainiac.

Now I don't know why Tellus' message would be so painful, but I thought the layout here with a montage of the ongoing action was nice.


Another recurring plot point in the book (and even Last Stand #1) has been Supergirl's growing status among her people. Whether she knows it or not, Kara has grown to be an important person in the New Krypton culture. I can remember when New Krypton first started that Gates and Igle said that Supergirl was sort of a princess on her homeworld.

It is one thing to have that stature simply because her mother is head of the council. It is quite another to earn it. Being on the front lines here, bringing home Reactron, ... it's all made Supergirl a leader on the planet. It is interesting that she doesn't realize it herself. So I like that Mon-El recognizes her growth and potential and tells her so.

Her response is swift, charming, and somewhat unexpected. A kiss for luck? I suppose she could be overcome with such happiness that Mon regards her as a leader that she needed to express herself.

But I wonder if this was thrown in to reflect the kiss we saw in the 'Origins and Omens' piece so long ago. I thought it was going to be Freddy Freeman all this time, but that kiss never happened in Cry For Justice. Maybe Gates realized he needed to show a kiss to cross that premonition off of a 'to do' list.

While Mon-El flies off to help Superman in Brainiac's ship, Supergirl does her best to rally the Kryptonians.

Unfortunately, the prejudices of the guilds don't let them work together as a fighting unit. Each guild does their own thing, leaving the city with a disorganized and shoddy defense.

Supergirl realizes that New Krypton needs a true leader, someone who can rise above the Guilds. She thinks that person is her mother Alura. I think we know that person is Superman.

Supergirl rushes to her mother's aid, assuming that Alura has been threatened by Brainiac probes. Instead Kara finds Alura fighting with Superboy.

Alura knows that Zod has branded Conner and the Legion as outlaws. She also knows the last human to wear the S-shield was Superwoman. Assuming the worse, Alura attacks him.

And when Kara runs in on their fight, she decides to end it.

I love this panel, Conner flying out of the building after being on the receiving end of Supergirl's right hook. It is the point of view I like, the buildings below Conner as he rockets away.

While I am usually tired of seeing Supergirl fight other heroes, I thought this sequence made a bit of sense. Kara was defending her mother after all. But after this punch, she immediately defends Conner and the Legion to her mother. It's almost she knows that punch was the quickest way to end the stand-off.


For the second straight issue though, Supergirl needs a last second rescue. Subjected to the red sun rays again, Kara and Alura are about to be killed when Superboy returns and dismantles the marauding robots.

I like how Supergirl is willing to try most anything in the heat of battle, even picking up a nearby rifle. It reminded me a bit of her fighting Reactron when powerless and she picked up a piece of rebar.


Once safe, Supergirl tells Alura of the Legion's mission and challenges her to stand up to General Zod. It is a very strong moment for Kara. And it is fruitful. Alura pardons the Legionnaires and sends Supergirl off with them to take the fight to Brainiac.

It is a good moment for many reasons, but it certainly shows how much the mother and daughter's relationship has changed recently. It actually seems to be a relationship! Gone, it seems, are the days where Alura yelled and Kara cried. It again shows how much Kara has matured recently.

Alura's pardons do not please Zod, setting up a confrontation between the two leaders of the planet.

I thought this was a very good issue pushing the plot of Last Stand forward but having Supergirl as the star and not one of a cast of many. The interactions with Mon-El, Superboy, and Alura showcased the character nicely. Gates has such a great handle on these characters. Their lines just seem so natural.

And Jamal Igle continues to produce great work on this book. This issue really lets him shine with a number of splash pages and near splash pages throughout. I wish I could have posted them all.

It'll be nice to see Supergirl leading the Legion again.

Overall grade: A

Thursday, December 24, 2009

March Solicits

I usually like to wait for all the DC solicits to come out before I post here just in case I am surprised by something (for example last month's Ame Comi statue). While there are no happy surprises (when is that Landry Walker Batman/Supergirl brave and Bold issue going to come out!), there is a lot going on with 'Brainiac and the Legion of Super-heroes' in March.

Here is the link to Newsarama's post:
http://www.newsarama.com/comics/091218-superman-march-2010-solicitations.html


SUPERGIRL #51

Written by STERLING GATES
Art by JAMAL IGLE & JON SIBAL
Cover by JOSHUA MIDDLETON

“Brainiac & The Legion of Super-Heroes” Part 2! Amidst Brainiac’s assault on New Krypton, General Zod has branded the Legion of Super-Heroes terrorists and imprisoned them! Superboy will do his best to free them, but he’ll have to go through Supergirl first! That’s right, it’s the Super-battle of the sexes you’ve been waiting for! Poor Ma Kent is going to be so disappointed in them...

So this is part 2 of the of the big storyline.

First off, great cover by Middleton with Supergirl using a Brainiac probe as a cudgel. Nice!

But why would Supergirl stop Superboy unless this is some mandate from Alura. I can't imagine Kara not trusting Conner. It has been a while since we have seen Supergirl fighting another hero (something that seemed to happen monthly early on in this series). In fact, we have seen this fight before in Supergirl #2.

Hopefully Supergirl does the right thing here and eventually sides with the good guys.



SUPERMAN: LAST STAND OF NEW KRYPTON #1

Written by JAMES ROBINSON & STERLING GATES
Art by PETE WOODS
Cover by ANDY KUBERT
1:25 variant cover by MARCOS MARZ

The new Superman crossover event “Brainiac & The Legion of Super-Heroes” begins here, in this first issue of a 3-part miniseries! It’s New Krypton’s worst nightmare as Brainiac attacks the planet, determined to recapture the city of Kandor! But General Zod has been waiting for this moment since Brainiac first attacked Old Krypton – he has a plan to save his people, but at the cost of Earth and the future as we know it! So it’s up to Superman, Supergirl, Superboy and the Legion of Super-Heroes to stop the two madmen before they destroy everything!


Zod versus Brainiac? The future hanging in the balance? Sounds like fun!

As I said before, I trust the creative team brought on board here so I look forward to this.



SUPERMAN: SECRET ORIGIN #5

Written by GEOFF JOHNS
Art and cover and 1:10 variant cover by
Gary Frank & Jon Sibal
Superman versus Metallo – for the first time! Witness the origin of one of Superman’s most-feared foes, as an attack by Lex Luthor goes awry and gives birth to the evil of Metallo. Can an inexperienced Man of Steel handle a foe with a heart of Kryptonite? Meanwhile, Lois Lane and Perry White are close to revealing Luthor as the monster that he is – but are they willing to pay for that truth with their lives?

Sigh ... this issue is pushed back to March.

While I usually wail and gnash my teeth about delays, I will look the other way here a bit. This mini-series is sort of outside continuity and so doesn't need to be released in a timely fashion (other than to appease my once-a-month schedule).

That said, shouldn't DC have waited until enough of this book was done so that it could be released monthly? Delays on books is my biggest pet peeve with comics.

But since the quality of this book has been so high, I can wait ... at least a little bit.


SUPERMAN #698

Written by JAMES ROBINSON
Art BERNARD CHANG & JAVIER PINA
Cover by JULIAN LOPEZ & BIT

“Brainiac & The Legion of Super-Heroes” Part 3! Superman is trapped on Brainiac’s ship while New Krypton burns! Mon-El will need to call upon all the skills he’s learned in the last year if he’s going to have a chance of freeing the Man of Steel! Plus, what secret about Brainiac will the duo learn that may help turn the tide?

New Krypton burning?! I have to think that New Krypton comes out much worse for wear after this mini-series, prompting the events of War of the Supermen'. If New Krypton is razed there may be no place for the surviving Kryptonians to go but Earth.

Hopefully some of the background story about Mon-El (on/off powers, lack of a Phantom Zone to go back to) will be figured out before this story. I'd hate to think his powers would blink off in Brainiac's ship.



ACTION COMICS #887

Written by GREG RUCKA & ERIC TRAUTMANN
Co-feature written by JAMES ROBINSON & GREG RUCKA
Art by PERE PEREZ
Co-feature art by CAFU
Cover by KALMAN ANDRASOFSZKY

In this corner – the already beaten, exhausted and bruised Nightwing & Flamebird! And in this corner – the reincarnation of the all-powerful Kryptonian sun god Rao! Place your bets! (Smart money’s on the sun god.)

I have to say I have come to like the Nightwing and Flamebird characters and I hope that they find a place in the DCU after this year.

Could Rao be what Jax-Ur is working on cloning? I love a good brawl and this one looks to fit the bill.




ADVENTURE COMICS #8-9

Written by JAMES ROBINSON & STERLING GATES
Co-Feature written by ERIC TRAUTMANN
Art by JULI¡N L”PEZ & CLAYTON HENRY
Co-feature art by PIER GALLO
Covers by FRANCIS MANAPUL
1:10 variant covers by JOE QUINONES & DUNCAN ROULEAU

ADVENTURE COMICS ships twice this month as this spring’s Superman event “Brainiac & The Legion of Super-Heroes” starts with a prologue in #8 and reaches a boiling point in #9!
Starting way back in “The Lightning Saga,” various clues have been planted about a group of Legionnaires undercover in the 21st century. Who are they and why are they here? And what does their mission have to do with the fate of New Krypton? James Robinson (SUPERMAN) and Julian Lopez (WORLD’S FINEST) may have an answer or two!

Meanwhile, in a tale of the 31st century by Sterling Gates (SUPERGIRL) and Clayton Henry (ADVENTURE COMICS), the Legion of Super-Heroes infiltrates a hidden Legion of Super-Villains base! The horrifying plans Brainiac 5 discovers inside will alter Superman’s life – FOREVER!

Plus, in the co-feature by Eric Trautmann (ACTION COMICS) and newcomer Pier Gallo, learn more about General Lane’s Human Defense Corps – Earth’s best line of defense against the looming Kryptonian threat!

After months of seeing some Legionnaires hanging out in the 21st century, I am happy to see their storyline finally brought to the forefront.

I am an old-time Legion fan and have been looking forward to the upcoming Legion comic. This seems like a great way to kick-start that title (I assume within the Adventure label).

And there are enough mysteries here to get my attention. Why are the LSH here? Why the heck are the LSV here? And what will Brainiac 5 discover?

Like many, I have not liked the re-imagining of some of the Legion costumes. Dawnstar and Sensor Girl stand out as particular' fashion don'ts'.

Still, I am happy to see the Legion being part of a big DC arc.



SUPERMAN 80-PAGE GIANT #1

Written by KATHRYN IMMONEN, BEN MCCOOL & OTHERS
Art by CLAYTON HENRY, JULIAN LOPEZ & OTHERS
Cover by AARON LOPRESTI

A thrilling collection of up-and-coming talent tackles Superman and the heroes of Metropolis! Packed with guest stars galore including Bizarro, Lois Lane and many more, these timeless tales of The Man of Steel are destined to thrill!

I don't necessarily know if I am going to pick up this book. It will probably depend on what else is coming out the week it is released. Still, I like Immonen, Henry, and Lopez ... so it will probably end up in my pile.

March seems to be a big month for the super-titles and my two favorite DC creations (Supergirl and the Legion) will have big parts to play. So I have high hopes here!