Friday, November 28, 2008

Middleton On Supergirl #38


Over on his blog (http://joshuamiddleton.blogspot.com/), Josh Middleton posted the final cover for Supergirl #38, released in February. It has a much more cosmic appearing cover than the one seen on the DC Comics website.

Here is what he had to say about it:

Here is the cover to Supergirl issue 38. It is drawn in ink and colored in Photoshop. It grew increasingly colorful and "glowy" as I went along. When I started out, I rendered the background character (Superwoman) in natural light, with a lot of contrast and a fair amount of detail. Unfortunately, it looked like a Sears portrait, so I kept working on it. I knew what I wanted, something atmospheric and somewhat cosmic, but for whatever reason, I kept drawing a blank on how to do it. Eventually, with a lot of constructive criticism from my wife, I stumbled onto something that worked well enough.

My wife also had me reduce the size of Supergirl's left hand, which was originally rather large, although I didn't see it as the enormous baseball mitt that my wife did. Apparently, I tend to draw overly large hands with some regularity. I have also learned that I am inclined to draw gigantic heads. My wife claims that Supergirl's noggin on the cover of issue 35, the newspaper cover, is a good example of my pumpkin-headed tendencies.

Now that is an eye-catching cover. Even the cosmic effect has an almost supernatural feel to it. I mean, if I wasn't buying the title that cover would make me pause a second as I perused the racks. Isn't that what a cover artist is supposed to do!

And I love the look on Kara's face. It is almost as if the thought of Superwoman is dominating Kara's thoughts, like a danger on the horizon.

And it appears Superwoman's eyes are blue. Hmmm ... does that limit the guesses on her identity? Does it give more credence to my ridiculous 'Kara clone' theory?

I am really looking forward to this storyline.

Thursday, November 27, 2008

Happy Thanksgiving


Happy Thanksgiving to all!

I could not find any specific Supergirl/Thanksgiving moments in a brief perusal of my collection although one must exist. So instead I treat you to this cover from Adventure Comics #394 drawn by Kurt Schaffenberger. In this near incomprehensible story, Kara gets thrown in jail by an intergalactic tyrant after she attempts to dismantle his dangerous 'Zenith Weapon'.

In the story the prisoners beg for a meal to be served and are forced to fight over some scraps. Reminds me of some Thanksgiving tables I have sat at. Please, no food riots on turkey day. Hee hee.

In the end, the other prisoners turn out to be super-heroines from other planets and they all team up to end the threat. You have to give thanks for the Silver Age.


On a different note, I just want to give thanks to everyone who visits this blog and comments. I started this blog on a complete whim, a way to get some ideas I had about Supergirl out of my head and into text form. I never expected that there would be others out there that not only had the same passion for the character that I have but have also found the blog and like it! This blog has really been a perfect creative outlet for me and reading other fan's thoughts about the character is wonderful. It really has been a great thing for me.

Thanks to all! Hope you all have a great holiday!

Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Review: Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom #2


The second issue of Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom was released last week, part of the biweekly schedule of this 5 part miniseries. You may recall that the first issue was not exactly awe-inspiring, what with Kara getting a beat down from Maelstrom as well as a verbal lashing from Superman.

This issue doesn't start out well with it characterization of Supergirl either.

Word balloons are fairly rare on covers these days. On this cover, Kara ignores Superman's warnings about the planet saying 'relax Kal, what could possibly hurt us out here?' all while putting her hair up in a pony tail. It feels like superficial Kara all over again. And having her putting her hair back while speaking rather than just standing there, it smacks of some immaturity.


The issue starts immediately with action as Superman and Supergirl are defending themselves with sticks against some monstrous aliens. Superman provides some exposition here. He has brought himself and Kara to this planet in a red star system to help train her to act without relying solely on her powers. He also hopes that it will allow them to grow closer.

Seems like something of a silly plan. First off, these beasts are huge and appear dangerous. Both Superman and Supergirl nearly fall off a cliff to their deaths early on. Doesn't this seem irresponsible of Kal? Risky? Are the lessons Kara might learn here worth the risk?


We then cut to Apokolips where Maelstrom is getting her own dangerous education. Remember, for going to Earth she is being punished ... forced to fight gladiator style. Surprisingly, she makes short work of a death squad, killing them for the glory of Darkseid. He rewards her by sending her to the slave pits.

It is clear that Palmiotti and Gray are trying to show some similarities between Maelstrom and Supergirl. Even the art helps out ... notice how the whip forms an 'S' in 2 panels, even aligning over her chest.

Both Supergirl and Maelstrom are young and trying to find their way. Both are trying to impress or gain favor with the imposing men in their lives. Kara wants to understand Kal, figure out why he does what he does, and see if she wants to follow in his footsteps. But most of all, she wants him to respect her, see her as more than a child. Maelstrom is also trying to rise from her perceived lowly status and gain Darkseid's favor ... but more, she feels she deserves to be his consort. Talk about trying to grab the brass ring.

Back on the red sun planet, Supergirl asks Superman what we all were thinking: what if we die here? Why come to this place where they are powerless and 'play human'.

Kal tells her he does not play at being a human; he considers himself human.


And Earth has its troubles. They aren't as enlightened as the Krypton Kara grew up on. Man needs their help, but not as rulers.

Supergirl continues to push him. Shouldn't Superman be doing more to enlighten mankind? Shouldn't he be spreading the Krypton ways in an effort to improve Earth?


Superman gently reminds her that Krypton wasn't completely enlightened. The people there didn't listen to Jor-El's warnings.

Regardless, Superman tells Kara that mankind needs to grow as a race on our own rather than by following the Kryptonian ideal. He lives as one of us. His responses as Clark are not acting, they are real and based on his upbringing.


While Kara debates with Kal, Maelstrom attempts to organize the slaves in the pits in hopes of escape. The other slaves do not join her and as a result she is overwhelmed by the guards. Now there will be more punishment ... isolation.

Meanwhile, the debate continues to rage on between the super-cousins.

Kara again brings up the danger in this little camping trip, wondering when the lesson is over. Superman calls her passive aggressive and tells her to get some sleep. Appropriately annoyed, Kara tells him to stop treating her like an overtired infant.



Frustrated, she storms off into the wilderness lamenting the lack of toilet paper and television ...


Only to find herself alone and surrounded by aliens.

Well, I think this is a better issue than the last one. While Superman continues to treat Supergirl like a little girl at least she debates him as an equal rather than simply deferring. I have to agree with her ... going to a dangerous planet like this seems hazardous to their health. At least she calls him on it a couple of times. Her responses do occasionally sound a bit superficial.

Still, Superman's attitude seems more like the Silver Age Superman who chastised her all too often. And I don't quite know what his agenda is here. If it simply physical training on a red sun world that's fine. But it seems like this is supposed to teach her some wisdom and I haven't wrapped my head around what it could be.

Maelstrom also shows some potential here. She clearly reveres Darkseid and yet continues to defy standard Apokoliptian ways. Organizing a potential slave revolt? Sort of impressive.

And, the art is typically delicious Phil Noto. I really like his Supergirl. The book is colored a bit darkly. I had to brighten up the scans so you could see the details.

So while I don't like how Superman is treating Supergirl in this book, I think she sort of held her own here. And that seems a step up from issue one.

Overall grade: C

Monday, November 24, 2008

Rich Buckler Commission


While I am usually unable to travel to distant comic book conventions, I am blessed with friends who can. I also am blessed that the same friends will always do the leg work of obtaining commissions for me at these cons.

The latest commission is posted above and was drawn by Rich Buckler at The National in New York earlier this month.

Buckler is an old-timer best known for his work on the Fantastic Four in the 1970's. He also created Deathlok around the same time. That said, his career has been prolific and he has drawn just about every character there is.


I figured he was a great addition to my collection because he drew one of the most famous images of Supergirl, the cover of The Daring New Adventures of Supergirl #1. This particular cover is fairly well known.

Heck, it was made into a stamp by the USPS.

I was lucky enough to also have my copy of the issue signed by Mr. Buckler. I had it signed by interior artist (and living legend) Carmine Infantino at a previous convention.

I think this is a great commission!

Sunday, November 23, 2008

Review: Tiny Titans #10


Tiny Titans #10 was released on Wednesday but really it read more like a Tiny World's Finest, starring occasional Titans Supergirl and Batgirl. Here was the promo lines.

It's girl's day out as Supergirl and Batgirl try to find the perfect location for a tea party. Let's just hope they don't forget about Steaky and Ace!

It was a fun read for a number of reasons. It also was further testament that 2008 is The Year of Streaky.

The issue starts out with this opening panel joke about the flight capabilities of the Super-Pets! Check it out! A Comet appearance! And, as always, Kara is serenely floating above ground.

But on to the main story.

Supergirl gets permission from cousin Kal to play with the Titans. He reminds her that she needs to feed Streaky before she can go. But she is so excited, she just flies off.



A hungry Streaky discovers his empty bowl. After watching Krypto gobble up lunch, he decides to fly off after Supergirl so he can get fed.


In the meantime, Batgirl asks Commissioner Gordon for permission to play with the Titans as well. He says she can after she feeds Ace the Bat-Hound. Ace the Bat-Hound!

Overcome with excitement as well, she also leaves before feeding her pet. In perhaps my favorite bit of the book, she leaves the house on her tricycle in a clear homage to how the Yvonne Craig Batgirl left hers on the old Adam West Batman TV show. I am showing my age here ... but I wonder how many readers got the reference.

Ace discovers his empty bowl and runs after Batgirl.

The two girls arrive and find the Titans deserted. They decide to have a play date together. And what better fin than a tea party. They decide to play in Gotham City and leave the tower.


Streaky and Ace arrive to late, and realizing they are on a similar mission team up to chase down their owners and get fed.


It turns out that Gotham isn't the best place to have a quiet tea party. Killed Kroc shows up and begins to eat garbage. Horrified by this, the girls decide they need to set up somewhere else. They decide to try Metropolis and so leave.

Streaky and Ace show up shortly thereafter and let Kroc know who they are looking for. He points the way they should go.


Unfortunately, it turns out that Metropolis isn't a good place for a tea party either. Bizarro shows up and showers them with crumbs from his messy potato chip eating. Disturbed by his crumbs and confused by his backwards speech, they leave to find a neutral site for their tea party.

Alas, the hungry pets show up too late again but are shown the way to go by a surprisingly helpful Bizarro.

Finally, at a quiet neutral site, the tea party commences. Shortly after starting, the girls hear crying and whimpering. Realizing that heroes would investigate these noises, the girls follow the noises only to discover it is their hungry pets whimpering.

Oh the humanity!


The girls set up the tea party again, this time with some yummy food for their pets. And then to thank the folks who pointed the pets in the right direction, Kroc and Bizarro get an invite as well.

I have talked in the past about how oddly enjoyable this title has been. It is hard to say it is solely for kids when things like Yvonne Craig references are made. And while not present in this issue, it has shown some continuity hooks or at least the need for a superficial knowledge of Titans history to understand it fully.

The truth is it is a perfect bridge book for parents like me trying to get their children into comics. It is silly and innocuous enough for the Johnny DC group while throwing enough bones at folks like me to not have me cringe when I read it.

I mean I got to talk about Comet with the supergirls at home. One of them even tried to opposite-talk like Bizarro for a bit after reading the issue together.

As a result, I really cherish this book, especially when Supergirl stars.

Overall grade: a silly but satisfying A

Friday, November 21, 2008

Review: Supergirl #35


Supergirl #35 was released this week, the mid-point of the New Krypton storyline and the second issue by new creative team Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle.

I'll start out by saying that this issue was great. The team continued their 'soft reboot' of Kara explaining some of the more frustrating things about her characterization in the title so far. Despite concentrating on moving Kara's character forward, they also continued to move the New Krypton storyline forward as well. It is not easy to accomplish both. How many 'cross-over' issues in individual titles have little to do with the event they are supposedly connected to? Or worse, how many 'cross-over' issues in individual titles seem to force the event onto the character and do little for the character themselves? This issue did it right ... advancing both stories in a very natural organic way.



I thought I would also show the Stephane Roux variant cover of the issue. It's a nice image of a Supergirl in battle mode as seen reflected in a Brainiac drone's eye. Yes, this has nothing to do with the actual issue, but it is still nice.

This was a 1:10 variant and my comic store had 3 on the shelf. Simple math tells us that they therefore ordered 30 copies of the issue, a nice sign about anticipated sales.

The book opens with Sam Lane talking about how concerned he is about the Kryptonian presence on Earth.

But the scene shifts to Lana and Linda Lang's apartment where Alura makes her feelings known pretty clearly. Alura wants Kara to move to New Krypton for her safety. She reminds Kara that the city hates her, that Doomsday was most likely sent by the government, and that Kara belongs with her family.

I think it makes sense for Alura to feel this way. After all, she has been living decades in the bottle wondering what had happened to Kara. She risked everything to save Kara. She loves her ... of course she wants her back home. Now, breaking the glasses is a bit dramatic and might be a reminder of Alura's physicality. She did beat Doomsday to death after all.

I love how Supergirl almost wrote 'Kara's room' on a box but corrected herself and put Linda.


Surprisingly, Kara doesn't want to run back home with Mom and Dad. She has built a life for herself on Earth and wants to continue it.

I was worried how this was going to be portrayed. Why would it really make sense for Kara who has longed for Krypton, mourned her parents, and been shunned most of her life on Earth not run back to Kandor?

But then I remembered how she has lived on Earth for more then a year and has been on her own for the majority of it. She is now an independent young woman rather than a frightened adolescent. She has left the nest. Others on this blog have said she has 'gone native'.

Part of adolescence is finding your own way, making your own life. It would be hard to go back to a bedroom on Kandor and listen to what Mommy and Daddy had to say. Kara might want her parents to be a part of her life now, probably a big part. But "you can't go home again". She can't go back to being a little girl anymore. The dialogue here worked, explaining Kara's feelings in a believable way.

Alura storms off and Kara has a heart to heart with her father in which she divulges her jumbled memories (3 Zor-Els, 3 origin stories), her mood swings, and her crystal blood. Like any good physician, he makes the diagnosis from the history ... Kryptonite poisoning. K-poisoning can lead to personality changes, difficulty concentrating, hallucinations, even death.

So, do I like this as a catch-all for all the nonsense that has happened in this title?Does this explain 'kill Kal-El' Zor-El and ranger Zor-El and this Zor-El well enough? Does it explain the rave dancer versus the aggressive loner versus the 'saving Thomas' optimist?

The answer is I can deal with it. There is no easy way to explain all those differences. So it needed to be one big semi-palatable answer. And, I guess, this fits the bill. Kara was in that Kryptonite encrusted meteor around her ship for 3 decades. You would think if she was exposed to Kryptonite forthat long, she'd be dead.

That said, I have plenty of Silver Age issues where low-dose Kryptonite made Superman delusional and feverish, so that must be the way Gates is going. Add to that presumed partial shielding of her ship, it becomes plausible.

The truth is I would gladly accept any even semi-plausible story that would explain and eliminate the hateful Kara from the first 19 issues.

Now how Zor-El knows so much about Kryptonite poisoning given his time on Argo and in Kandor should have been Kryptonite free ... well I have no idea. But I can overlook that slight stumble (or if someone can explain it to me); this works out fine.

The world outside the Kryptonians keeps turning however.

One human taking advantage of it is Cat Grant who continues her merciless journalistic attack on Kara, here insinuating that Supergirl is leading a 'Kryptonian invasion'.
And Sam Lane isn't sitting pat either. He goes to area 7734 (get it ... it's hELL upside-down) and coaxes Reactron back into military action.


Knowing now that her jumbled memories and personality twitches are the result of K-poisoning, Kara gets put into a 'regenerative chamber' which will drain off the remaining radiation and cure her. Zor-El knows that the chamber might not be able to hold the energy drained from Kara, but still stays in the room with Alura to make sure Kara survives the process.

I show this panel for one reason.

That's right, there are bike shorts under the mini-skirt! I, for one, think it makes sense for Supergirl to wear them given all the flying she does. And, thankfully, it takes away the potential for the pandering and gratuitous panty shot we sometimes have been subjected to. It also eliminates the need for the skirt to defy physics and always stays down. I am completely okay with it.

But I know that when Renato Guedes added them to Kara's costume in his issues, the negative feedback about it was unprecedented and (I feel) unwarranted. Buckle up Mr. Igle ... my guess is the same folks might complain again.

The chamber works, draining Kara of the radiation. But as feared, the system overloads and a major bolt of K-energy hits Alura. More on my guesses behind this later.


With the Kryptonite drained away, Kara's memories of Argo City are restored.

She remembers how Zor-El reversed-engineered the force field from a Brainiac drone recovered from the Kandor site. She remembers her father trying to convince the Argo Science Council to consider evacuating Argo with space ships only to be refused (much like big brother Jor-El). And she remembers Brainiac's attack and being rocketed away to safety.This 'new origin' takes a lot of the Silver Age origin but updates it by including the Brainiac angle (both for the dome and destruction) and takes away the anti-Kryptonite and meteor angle.

Again, this all works here.

With her memory now intact, Kara now knows how much her parents love her ... enough to risk everything on Argo to save her, enough to risk everything right then to save her.

It leads to the tough question. She can't have both lives. She can't live as a Kryptonian and live as an Earthling as Linda Lang. She needs to decide which path her life will take.

She tells her family she needs some time.

But the K-poisoning is gone ... and with it all the terrible nonsense that I could not stand from the Kelly run!!! Hurray!

In some ways, Gates and Igle have a semi-clean slate onto which they can write their version of Kara. So far, so good.

The issue ends with our first glimpse at Superwoman. Here she is, in Kandor, watching the news while donning her outfit. While her hair looks brown here, she is in shadows so it could easily be blond.

She watches some footage of Kara and then hears the Kryptonian word for help.


And here is the first big shot of her.All right, so everyone has been trying to figure out who this Superwoman could be. Some think she's Thara Ak-var.My initial thought is that she is an update of Lesla Lar, maybe as a Kandor or Argo orphan taken in by the Els to fill Kara's void.

Then I thought it might be a Kara clone. Maybe Zor-El so missed his daughter while in the bottle, he cloned her.

But now I wonder if it isn't Alura. I have heard people on other boards and even on this blog (I think Mauricio) guess this. She has been very vocal in her desire to have Supergirl move back home to Kandor. Maybe a way to do that is to 'replace' her thus severing Kara's ties to Earth. And now we know she has been shot full of K-poisoning (getting back to the above panel) which can make you act oddly, taking on new personalities. Maybe the Superwoman personality is Alura's subconscious way of bringing Kara back into the fold.

Maybe it's time for another blog poll? Who is Superwoman?

Anyways, there was a lot to get through here. The big thing is we have a solid origin now, one devoid of crystal powers, Phantom Zone entities, and murderous tendencies. And it was explained in a neat plausible manner and in one fell swoop.

I have to say, it has been a while since I have been truly excited about this title. But I am now. The plot was great and the dialogue was spot on. The art continues to be amazing. Great job by the creative team!

Overall grade: A

Thursday, November 20, 2008

More Info About R.E.B.E.L.S.


The February solicits for DC included a new title called R.E.B.E.L.S. which builds off the old L.E.G.I.O.N. and R.E.B.E.L.S. comics. Written by Tony Bedard (who did some serviceable fill-in issues of Supergirl and Supergirl and the Legion of Super-Heroes).

Both Newsarama and CBR have interviews with Bedard about his love of the characters, their place in the DCU, and their relationship to the 31st century Legion.

Here are the links.
http://www.newsarama.com/comics/110820-Bedard-REBELS.html
http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=18891

As always, I advise reading both interviews in total. It is clear that Bedard has a love of these characters and their history and sounds pretty excited about the title.

Here are the Supergirl specific bits from the Newsarama post.

R.E.B.E.L.S. will focus on Brainiac 2, Vril Dox, as he builds a new group of interstellar mercenary police. "As R.E.B.E.L.S. begins, Brainiac 2 arrives on Earth, pursued by alien bounty hunters. We learn he’s been deposed, his interstellar police force stolen from him," Bedard explained. "Unfortunately, someone took control of his vast robot armada away from Dox. Now the peacekeeping force has become an army of occupation, and there’s a price on Dox’s head."
As a result, Dox comes to Earth seeking Supergirl, who "somehow holds the key to his comeback," the writer said, although he wouldn't give all the secrets away.


"With what she provides him, he will recruit a whole new team, take back control of L.E.G.I.O.N., and free the 83 worlds that paid him to keep them safe," Bedard said. "Well, that’s his intent, anyhow, but there are more than a few surprises ready to dash the best-laid plans of Brainiac 2. And since his new team is fighting against the forces of L.E.G.I.O.N., we’re going with the more apt title, R.E.B.E.L.S."

Bedard said that while the original L.E.G.I.O.N. team was set up as a sort of present-day analog of the Legion of Super-Heroes -- "you could even say they were a twisted reflection of the LSH," he said -- the new team reflects both heroes and villains of the 31st Century.

"The one member who returns from the original series is Strata, who hails from the same race as the classic Legionnaire, Blok," he said. "The rest are new characters that I think both Legion fans and new readers will really get a kick out of. Their names are Wildstar, Bounder, Tribulus and the Emerald Princess, and you’ll have to check out R.E.B.E.L.S. to get to know them."

I wonder if whatever she 'gives him' is somehow related to her time in the 31st century. Bedard definitely had Kara remember her LoSH time in his Countdown-related issue of Supergirl. In some ways that is the only indication we have that her Legion career is in Supergirl's continuity or that it was really her. (It is true that Johns had her in the future in Action Comics #850, so maybe there are 2 events linking her LoSH time and the present).

As for this title, most know I am also a big LoSH fan with Wildfire as my favorite Legionnaire. So this team of a female Wildfire named Wildstar, the Emerald Princess, and a Validus-looking creature called Tribulus is at least visually intriguing.

And with Kara involved at the beginning, looks like a new title will appear on my pull list.


As for the art, I have to say I am unfamiliar with Andy Clarke but what little I have seem makes me very impressed. He clearly has a fine-lined detailed style that just jumps off the page. CBR showed this page from R.E.B.E.L.S. with Supergirl swooping in to rescue Brainiac 2. Bedard describes him as a cross between Travis Charest and Kevin Maguire and that is high praise. I get just the slightest hint of Geof Darrow in the detailing (although no where near as busy).

The first issue is to be released on February 11, 2009.