Friday, October 10, 2008

Cosmic Adventures in the Eighth Grade sneak peek

The media blitz for Supergirl continues as Newsarama has just posted a 5 page preview of the first issue of Supergirl: Cosmic Adventures in the Eight Grade, slated for a 12/3 release. Here is the link for your giddy perusal.

http://www.newsarama.com/php/multimedia/album.php?aid=23223

I have been excited about this comic since first hearing about it. Written by Landry Walker and drawn by Eric Jones, it should be a great comic for tweeners. And, of course, it will introduce the character of Supergirl to a new generation of devotees.

We have already learned that in this comic her secret identity will be Linda Lee. We already have heard that Streaky will show up. I think I read that Comet the Super-horse may also appear. And now that dialogue has been added to the preview, a reporter asks her if she is Superman's emergency secret weapon. All of that harkens back to a simpler time, a more innocent time for Kara.

The previewed pages look like her origin will be covered in short order, with her rocket crash landing on page 1.


Here is my favorite panel from page 5. Supergirl sure looks cute and fun. I like the pleated red dress look and the blue leggings make a nice touch of modesty for a 13 year old girl. I am probably dating myself, but when I saw this panel I immediately thought about this ...


Okay, I watched Bewitched in reruns in the afternoon. I'm not that old. Still, it was such an immediate conenction for me I wonder if it was intentional. Bewitched was certainly fun in a slapstick 70s sort of way so any feelings of nostalgia for the show I get is a positive.

Anyways, December certainly is a great month for Supergirl fans and this series' introduction is a big part of it.

Wednesday, October 8, 2008

Action Comics 870 Variant Cover


My thanks to talos and others who let me know about this great Andy Kubert variant cover for Action Comics #870 which is coming out today. I have read the spoilers about the death in this issue, not that it shocks me. No need to get more specific right now;I am sure I will have a review up within a few days.

As I have said recently, I am really impressed with the Supergirl promotion blitz which DC has been doing recently. This is a great example. This is a Superman book, but the variant cover is a showcase for Kara.

I love the layout here as well. Kubert puts Supergirl in a classic heroic position as she streaks to stop Brainiac's solar aggressor. And I love the intense look on her face. If this cover represents what happens in the issue, then Supergirl might be the hero who saves Earth from destruction, while Superman defeats Brainiac. How great would that be! Kara has been so scarred by Brainiac, by the destruction of Krypton and Argo City. It would be wonderful for the growth of her character to actually be able to say 'I saved my new world!'

Although I like Andy and Adam Kubert's art, Joe is my favorite Kubert.

Here is Adam Kubert's take on Supergirl. This is the variant cover of Supergirl #23, Kelley Puckett's first issue.

Tuesday, October 7, 2008

Poll results and reboot thoughts


A little Kara philosophy in this post, so bear with me.

Two weeks ago I posted a poll on this blog asking people to vote for their favorite Supergirl costume. First off, let me thank all of you who voted and left comments. It is overwhelming to me that 67 people have even found this blog, let alone took the time to vote. Overwhelming. Thanks again!

And yes, the Matrix style costume won the poll, hence the great Jackson Guice cover above, showcasing that uniform so wonderfully. However this was no landslide win. In fact, I was surprised at how close the poll was. Here are the results.


Matrix: 16 votes
Current/Turner: 13 votes
Hot pants/70s: 12 votes
Crisis/head band: 10 votes
Original/blue skirt: 8 votes
White shirt/Timmverse: 5 votes
70s variant: 3 votes

That is a pretty amazing spread. I think it actually speaks a lot about Supergirl fans in general. We tend to be very attached to Supergirl, almost zealous. No one seems to like Supergirl a little bit. If you like her, you tend to love her. And yet, Supergirl fans seem to be divided amongst ourselves despite our common love of the character. We can't even agree on her clothes.

I have been reading a pretty wild thread on Geoff Johns Comic Bloc Forums in which Supergirl #34 is being discussed. Most people really liked the new direction, myself included. I thought it was a step in the right direction to bring back a heroic and noble Kara. But there are several people on that thread that absolutely hate it. They hate the secret identity. They hate her 'losing her edge'. It is an incomprehensible response for me. How could I have loved this issue so much and yet other Kara fans hate it with the same intensity?

I think it boils down to Kara being a pretty complicated character who has grown a lot ... changed a lot ... throughout her history. As a result, fans can have a very specific and valid feel for what they want her character to be like. And when the character is not written that way, they feel cheated. Heck, they can even feel cheated if the costume isn't the one they like. And you can see from this sampling poll here, there is a contingent of Supergirl fans for each of them!

Superman is written one way. He is the ultimate hero, the ultimate good guy, the one who is able to see the 'right' thing to do and does it. For me that makes him difficult to relate to. He is invulnerable, unstoppable, bigger than life, and completely ethical. I am not that good. I am human with human foibles and failings. I can aspire to be Superman, but I can't really relate to him.

And I think that therein lies what I love about Kara. I was drawn to comics because I like the genre. I like reading about super-heroics. I was drawn to Supergirl because she had those powers, she lived those stories, but she also seemed to be trying to find herself too. She could even fail, just as I could fail.

So when she struggled with her relationships or wondered if she would forever be alone, I 'got' that. When she was trying to figure out what she wanted to do in life ... TV reporter, soap opera star, guidance counselor, or grad student... I understood that too. And when, unlike Superman, she got frustrated and lashed out swiftly and violently against villainy, something we have seen throughout her comic career, I could understand that response. She never seemed as restrained and staid as Superman. She might even have a temper like I do. She was easy to relate to and as a result a better read.


Now the Supergirl I started reading was the Superman Family dollar comics and the Daring New Adventures of Supergirl. I did not grow up with the Kara who listened to Superman and stayed hidden, who never seemed to reach Superman's expectations. But when I finally read those stories, I could see her evolution from the meek young girl in Midvale to the independent and strong Linda Danvers I fell in love with.

The problem with all these sides to Kara (struggling for acceptance, looking for love, finding her place on Earth, strong-willed and independent young woman, and super-strong kick butt heroine) is that her fans can want to see one side of her more than another, to look at the jewel of the character but want to focus on only one facet.

So someone can like a conflicted Kara trying to find her way in the world and it is a valid interpretation. These folks most likely hated the opinionated anti-hero we saw in the first 19 issues of this current title.

And another fan can like the opinionated, 'take charge' loner Kara we saw in the first 19 issues and feel that version is valid. (I really don't ... that Kara was not a hero but a self-absorbed killer.) So a Kara who tries to save a child from cancer or cries when a negative editorial is written about her makes little sense to that group of fans.


You almost could ask 'will the real Supergirl please stand up?'

All these shades of gray that make up "Supergirl" (I guess the concept of Supergirl rather than this particular one) make her a rich and and wonderful and complicated character to write stories for. That said, it would be hard (if not impossible) for a creative team to write the 'perfect' Supergirl, someone all Supergirl fans like a lot ... someone who can unite all the Kara fans under one banner.

Now one issue does not make a perfect run, but in issue 34 we see a Supergirl who drops a garbage truck on a villain and takes out a griffin. We see a Kara who is questioning her place in the world. We see a young woman who faces her personal enemy (albeit with a cute note) and decides to do what is right. We see the many shades of her personality just like we all have different sides to ourselves. I will say it again ... it is the readers' ability to relate to Kara that makes her so compelling.

This issue just felt like Kara to me.

I do not envy Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle. They have to please a very vocal Supergirl fan base who have very strong ideas about her. But I would rather be writing or drawing a character that people cared about this much than one people could not care less about.

Hopefully, these ramblings make some sense ...

Monday, October 6, 2008

Reviews on Supergirl #34


Well the reviews around the web have all been very positive! It is great for there to be so much positive news about Kara in the comics world. Anyways, a simple search will bring you to all the rave reviews that I have not linked to. These were the ones that stuck out in my mind. Here are the links and some blurbs.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=18308

The Buy Pile: It's a big surprise to see "Supergirl" #34 almost not suck (although it does echo the "get a secret identity" shtick from some issues back) with some diminished whining from the title character, a Peter Parker-esque turn in what she does with her time and some okay (if needlessly chatty) action scenes, all wonderfully drawn by the illustrious and praiseworthy Jamal Igle.

The thing that got me here is that the writer of The Buy Pile on CBR has routinely gone out of his way to really throw the Supergirl title under the bus. He really did not like this title and he let people know it. So for him to give it any praise is huge.

http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=user_review&id=387

4.5 out of 5. 5 I found the book entertaining. Gates, Igle and company are crafting a nice little niche into the Superverse for themselves and I look forward to seeing what the future holds for this title.


4.5 out of 5 on CBR. I don't see many issues get that score. CBR! That is great press for a huge comic book audience.

http://comics.ign.com/articles/915/915390p1.html

7.6/ 10 For the first time in a long time, and maybe even ever, I was able to enjoy an issue of Supergirl. It looks like this book has finally found its direction thanks to a very competent creative team. Not only is it clear that Gates is up to the task of keeping stride for stride with Johns and Robinson, but he's found a talented brother in arms in artist Jamal Igle. Igle's work here is crisp and bold without ever trying to be too flashy, which is all you can ask for from an artist trying to get a title back on track.


Another wonderful review. And everyone is just gushing over Igle's art. He just seems so perfectly suited for the title.


http://www.comicsbulletin.com/reviews/122300357543494.htm

3.5/5 Sterling Gates has done a nice job with setting this series up for a potentially good future. If he can keep pace with Robinson and Johns then there is no telling how good this book could become. With enough work and retooling, Supergirl is likely to become one of my favorite characters.


Again, this is another reviewer who seems ready to jump on the Supergirl band wagon after not being too keen on the character.


http://www.wizarduniverse.com/100208tmqb3.html

Gates and Igle quickly proved themselves as a creative team more than ready to take Supergirl flying to new heights.


Even Wizard praised it. Even people on the Bendis boards praised it! I hope Gates and Igle give themselves a pat on the back for making Kara relevant again. In everything I have read by them I doubt they will rest on their laurels.




And not only have the reviews been great, there have been lots of people saying their store was sold out of the issue. That is great news! I am foreseeing a second printing ... maybe with that great Jamal Igle promo art work. I do recall Igle saying somewhere that DC had this piece colored for print 'sometime'.

Saturday, October 4, 2008

It Came From The Back Issue Box: Supergirl #11 and 12


We all just read the current Supergirl’s battle with Silver Banshee in the excellent Supergirl #34. I thought it would be nice to review the prior Supergirl’s interactions with the villain back in 1997’s Supergirl #11-12.

As many know, I loved the Peter David Supergirl title. The title constantly was looking at the definitions of good and evil, the role of religion in a super-powered world, the randomness of the universe, and how struggling to do good can often lead to bad outcomes.

That Supergirl was the manifestation of the Earth Angel of Justice, a physical representation of God’s will formed when someone (in this case the Matrix protoplasm Supergirl) sacrifices themselves to save someone damned (here Linda Danvers a demon-worshipping murderess). This was early on in the series, just as some of Supergirl’s angelic qualities are coming to the forefront, as she is learning about herself. At this point she was still questioning what she was … an artificial life-form who absorbed a human’s memories or something more.


These issues start with Supergirl accidentally releasing the Silver Banshee from an underground prison at the site of a Chaos Stream. Supergirl thought she was simply saving a trapped woman.

Rather than immediately fighting each other, the Banshee simply walks away while Supergirl has to fight a demon spawn which attacks her from the river. It is clear that Silver Banshee has no memories of her time as a demon; indeed she is mad.


Supergirl awakens from her battle in Hell. She meets Lord Satanus who derides her for freeing the Banshee from her prison. He tells Supergirl that the Banshee cannot maintain her current form for long; she will need to possess a kindred spirit or she will dissipate. Also throughout this conversation, Satanus begins to drop more hints about Supergirl’s current status. He tells her that Linda’s soul, destined for Hell, has been saved by Matrix’s sacrifice; but also Matrix has been saved as well …elevated from a mere simulacrum.


He also calls Supergirl ‘the Blue Angel’, one of the ‘Chosen Ones’, and a ‘Guardian Angel.’

While many did not like this Earth Angel storyline, I really enjoyed it. It was compelling, interesting, and original. I never had a problem with accepting this semi-Vertigo feel to the character. I also had forgotten this meeting between Satanus and Linda in the past; how interesting now that Reign in Hell is ongoing.


After a skirmish in Linda’s hometown Leesburg, Supergirl appears to have beaten the Banshee. However, just as she is about to fade away, the Banshee finds a kindred spirit to merge with, Linda’s good friend Mattie Harcourt.

Mattie was an interesting character. She was a physician whose brother was killed in a random act of violence. She then resuscitated her brother’s killer in the ER. She had lingering issues that many of us have … why wasn’t she there to save him, why do bad things happen to good people, why is her brother dead while his killer lives?


In a fit of anger, Mattie/Banshee swears she will kill her brother’s murderer. And to make sure Supergirl cannot interfere she will kill the hero. She screams ‘Supergirl’ which, given the Banshee’s powers, should kill Supergirl if that is her ‘true’ name.


Remarkably, Supergirl lives. She is not Supergirl … she is Linda. Or Linda is her. Either way, this moment of joy as Supergirl realizes she is real, a human, not a thing is one of the best moments of this story.


Supergirl races to the local home for the criminally insane to stop the Banshee. There she tries to draw out the inherent goodness in Mattie to break her possession. She tells her she needs to let go of the hate in her soul, let go of the malice she has for her brother’s killer. Supergirl reveals her identity to Mattie; she is Linda, a friend, who is there for her. They embrace and Mattie is released from the Banshee’s control.

Supergirl then holds the Banshee and comforts her about the fears Banshee’s original mortal host had. Without a body, the Banshee fades away.

I feel I am in the minority of Supergirl fans when I say I loved Peter David’s run, especially the first 50 issues, which were heavy on the philosophy and religious themes. The growth of that character, her slow fall from grace, and subsequent redemption makes that run one of my favorites of all time.

The art here is by Greg Land, and it appears to be before he went heavily into his ‘100% cheesecake, lightboarded recreations of models’ style. His art is solid here.

Overall grade: B

Thursday, October 2, 2008

Review: Supergirl #34 - The Wait Is Over!


Pardon the long post, but there is a lot to cover here.

It was back in late June that Kara fans first learned that Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle were taking over the Supergirl title. Since then there have been numerous interviews and panels in which the team described their approach to the character. They wanted to make Kara a likeable character again, a heroic character again; someone who will try and fail and grow and try again and succeed. We have seen glimpses of this ‘new Kara’ in Action Comics and Final Crisis. Even though I liked Kelley Puckett’s run on Supergirl, I have been looking forward to Supergirl #34, the new team’s first issue for some time. It finally was released yesterday and I can say succinctly it did not disappoint.


Before we get into the issue itself, I also have to commend the DC promotion for the title as they try to bring in new readers. We saw preview pages on Newsarama; we had interviews on CBR. Supergirl is currently prominently displayed on their home page. And we get this very nice Fernando Pasarin variant cover, enticing to collectors and dealers alike. I love the joy on Wonder Woman’s face as she and Supergirl take out this griffin. But on to the issue …


As hinted at all along, the issue starts with a shot of the front page of the Daily Planet showing Cat Grant’s ‘Why the world doesn’t need Supergirl’ opinion piece. Despite Clark and Lois’ attempts to persuade Perry White to scrap or bury the piece, the decision is made to run it on the front page.


Cat actually does a good job of defending the merit of the piece listing off all the things that haven’t gone well for Kara recently: taking down Air Force One, hurting people during the Reactron rescue, leaving the Atlas battle, and not saving Thomas’ life. Of course, all the good things that happened during those incidents are conveniently not discussed.

I am so glad that the current team is taking on this perception and not forgetting Supergirl’s recent past. I feel sometimes when new creative teams begin a ‘bold new direction’ they simply ignore recent history and start with a blank slate. It would have been easy to simply not mention the prior runs on this title, as out of synch they have felt with each other. That would be the easy way out. So kudos to the new team for taking on Kara’s confusing and conflicted history head on.


Oblivious of the smear campaign, Kara battles the Silver Banshee above Metropolis. Unfortunately the battle lands them in the middle of the Metropolis Monarchs baseball game.

Acting quickly, Supergirl saves a player and (in one of my favorite panels) swiftly decisively takes out the Banshee by dropping a garbage truck on her! What a great action shot!


While pleased with herself, the crowd is not so happy as seen above. First we get a Baywatch shot of Kara smiling about her victory. If this was TV, a slight breeze would be blowing out her hair. That happy moment ends as quickly as the battle with a soda to the face from the disgruntled crowd. Rather than thank Supergirl for saving them, the crowd brings up the mess she made, how she interrupted the game, and tell her ‘The Daily Planet’ was right.


Not knowing what they mean about The Planet, Kara flies off and reads the Cat Grant piece. In what is probably my favorite panel from the book, we see a despondent Kara sitting in a windstorm of the paper. It's like her life is metaphorically swirling out of control around her. Now some might complain that this shows a weak Kara, but for me it was a moment of realism. Supergirl has been on Earth for a short period of time and has mostly strived to do good. Despite that, she never seems to catch an even break. Why shouldn’t she feel sad when no one mentions the good she has done and only mentions the bad?


She broods through until morning when Superman shows up with a coffee and advice. Throughout the conversation, Superman is completely supportive of Kara and recognizes her heroism. This is not the chastising Superman we have occasionally seen in this title. He is shocked when Kara asks her if he agrees with Cat and tells her she is ‘more than worthy’ of carrying on his legacy.

He does give her one piece of advice … get a secret identity. He tells Kara she needs some space to decompress. He does not want her to stop being a hero … just stop heroing for 24 hours a day.


Supergirl agrees and begins to ask advice of her other friends. First she talks to the Titans. Robin gives her Connor’s glasses telling her that Connor would be proud to have someone in the family using them. Then she talks to Wonder Woman who tells her that the mask that is worn by a hero is sometimes their secret identity, changing to Diana to prove the point.

I was never a big Connor fan but I feel this is a nice homage to his character. Superboy died saving the universe from Prime so I also think the glasses will be a reminder to Kara about the price and power of heroism.


Lastly, she talks to the Kents and Lana Lang. Kara talks about how Clark wanted her to hide from her problems in a secret identity, not exactly what he said but maybe how she interpreted it. Supergirl and Lana hit it off, both realizing that they have been running away from their problems and need to face them instead. They decide to face them together.


Cut to the Daily Planet again, where Cat Grant finds this card on her desk. This was a perfect response by Kara. It shows that Supergirl is not going to shy away from the Cat Grant problem, not run from the city. It shows self-confidence in an understated but powerful manner. She didn’t write ‘stop writing about me or I’ll pulp you’ or 'F U' like the Joe Kelly Kara might have.


And then the unveiling of the secret identity …. Linda Lang!!! Okay, so I like the use of Linda here, an obvious tip of the hat to prior Supergirls. Nice touch! Nice ending! This issue is what 'bold new direction' issues should be ... a recap of the character and a bunch of hooks to grab the readers and keep them coming back for more.

I am sure there will be people out there who did not like the issue because Kara seems weak, tearful, and too subservient to Superman. For me it didn’t feel that way at all. This felt like the natural ending to 3 difficult years of stories. Kara is bowed but not broken. In fact, she seems to have emerged stronger.

On top of this big thematic change, there were other nice touches throughout the issue, like Supergirl dropping Kryptonian words into her conversations. That just makes sense giving her background.

And the art by Jamal Igle was absolutely stunning. The battle scenes are crisp. Kara looks lovely and healthy. But what really impressed me were the facial expressions throughout the book, perfectly capturing the character’s feelings. I could post a dozen more panels of facial expressions that were spot on. I think Geoff Johns and Sterling Gates were right when they said Jamal hit this issue out of the park.

I wish there was one or two more issues before the new Krypton storyline so we could have the team really solidify their direction before a big cross-over event. But really I have nothing but praise for this issue.

Overall grade: A+

Wednesday, October 1, 2008

New Costume? Secret Identity?

Okay ... so I am stuck at work and I haven't to the comic book store to buy issue #34 yet.

But I am impressed with the comic media blitz that DC is rolling out for the book including the Newsarama links, a front and center shot of the cover on DCComics.com and now this interview with Sterling Gates on Comic Book Resources. Here is the link:


Now the interview is well worth reading and includes things like Gates' lifelong love of Kara (join the club) and his and Jamal Igle's approach to Supergirl.

But 2 images of Igle's stuck out.


1) Her costume: Look at this sketch of Supergirl by Jamal Igle. Notice the full shirt on the costume? I did. Looks almost Matrix-y, albeit with loose sleeve ends and the gold trim.

Now Igle has come out and said that he is merely 'tweaking the costume', not revamping it. So I don't know if this is what Supergirl will be wearing soon or just some concept art.


It is sort of a mirror position to this other promotional art piece of his that has been released.

And check out this one!


2) Secret identity: All along I have been saying that Kara needs a secret identity and the new team, while never confirming it, seemed to hint one was on the way. And now we see this picture of Linda Lang?? Ahhh, those dreaded initials L.L. crop up again. We know Lana is going to be a mentor to Kara in the new run. Looks like she will also provide her name for a secret identity.
And 'Linda' has sort of a Clark feel to her. I am sure she won't always look like Annie Hall. And I love the description ... quirky, cute, funny.

I, for one, am thrilled by both these pics and this new creative direction. Review of Supergirl #34 to come soon!