Review: Superman #42

Superman #42, the penultimate chapter of the Kingdom of Zod crossover, came out this week and brought us closer to an ending. But I don't know if it brought me closer to liking this event. So many questions. So many magical answers. So much I don't understand. 

Joshua Williamson does a solid job on this from a character viewpoint. There are good character bits for Prime and Superman. There is a wonderful moment for the cousins. And there is some intersesting interaction between Superman and this young Zod. There is even a nod to some Krypton history that might make me crack open old books to remind myself.

But the big parts of this story - the Kryptonite meteor, Zod's plot, the removal of the expanding Green K- have been inscrutable. Why would Zod want to invade Earth and thought the best way was to shower it with variant Green K? How did he get it? How did he coat it in inertron? Why did it grow? How did Superman deactivate it? All stuff I have to roll with and since all those are key points to the story, it feels like too much. In this issue we get a preview for what will for sure be the deus ex machina for the finale.

So will I be a bit happy to see this wrap up next week? Yes. It is too much of a headache to think about.

The art is a nice split between Eddy Barrows, who continues to shine and Eduardo Pansica, an old friend around these parts. Their styles are sort of similar so the issue flows fine. There are a couple of very well done big art moments that added some punch here. And I love love love the Takara variant cover above.

But on to the book.

Review: Superman Unlimited #17

Superman Unlimited #17 came out this week and I hope everybody read it because in a few short pages the biggest plot point of this title, an abundance of Kryptonite being on Earth, is wrapped up. The whole Green K plot has perplexed me. So no surprise, the solution to the plot perplexed me just as much. But more that just the Kryptonite plot, some other smaller plotlines are ended quickly. 

Writer Dan Slott introduced the Green K abundance way back in Superman Unlimited #1, which also introduced the new power where Superman can create a golden aura and become completely invulnerable to everything (although powerless for some time afterwards). 

But much of the Green K plot is unanswered. How did the Green K meteor get coated in intertron. Why would General Zod shoot his biggest weakness on a planet he wants to conquer? Why would he create a version of his weakness that can grow insanely and then put it on the planet he wants to conquer? Why does that Green K seem to wax and wane in its effect on Kryptonians depending on scene, issue, title? 

While the last two issues of Kingdom Of Zod have concentrated on the time travel Krypton story, this one is mostly on Earth. And with one more chapter and a special left, Slott wraps up this side of the event rapidly.

There are some fun moments in the book. There is an All-Star Superman nod. And frankly, I am glad this Green K plot seems to be done as it never grabbed me. But the way it ends feels quick and unsatisfying.

The art is split between Rachel Stott and Montos and the book looks good. The big action sequence in the middle where Superman ends the Kryptonite thread is done well on the page with widescreen pages and solid images of the world.

Will Kingdom of Zod be fondly remembered? We'll have to see how it wraps up. On to the book.

Review: Action Comics #1102

Action Comics #1102 came out last week, the next issue in the Kingdom Of Zod event, and the second chapter focusing on a time travel jaunt to Krypton before it exploded. I have struggled with the main plot of a Kryptonite plague happening on Earth. But chapters 5 and 6 of this event have been an interesting diversion, taking us back to Krypton and focusing on the two characters who would have the most interesting take on being on the planet again - Kara and young Clark.

Mark Waid has been doing a great job on the current Superboy stories in Action Comics, letting us see him at the earliest stages, learning his powers, and growing as a hero. But he barely knows about Krypton as a concept. So seeing him on Krypton, experiencing it for the first time, and knowing that perhaps he could change things and have it survive is all interesting. Waid clearly knows young Clark's voice and he makes these stories compelling. 

And Waid also loves Supergirl and she continues to shine in this Krypton arc, weighing her love of the planet and her need to keep the timeline and Superman's legacy intact. Supergirl might actually be the star of this issue.

The action is also great with Kara and Clark trying to escape a Krypton prison, get Ursa to stop talking, and get back to the time bubble. 

Montos is on art and his fine pencil style works well here. His fight scenes really shine as you see the effort and anger on the combatants.

On to the book.

Krypton Timeline In ‘Kingdom Of Zod’

In my review of Supergirl #17, I tried to piece together when our heroes' time travel trip to Krypton took place. Was the destruction imminent? Or was there some time.

Much of that was based on this shot (not shared in my review) of Kara seeing herself and her parents walking around the city. I put Kara at about 8-10 years of age. Assuming the origin of her being sent off to Earth at around age 16 to help protect Kal when he is a newborn is still intact, I wondered if we were about 5-10 years in the past.

That's a lot of story weight placed on one picture. And I have been told that kids are notoriously hard to draw. 

But the time period does impact the story. Ursa is trying to save Krypton and its people. How close are we? Has Jor-El discovered Krypton is dying? 

So I reached out to the creators on Bluesky.

All right, as an old time fan with a lot of continuity in my mind and in the midst of a timey-wimey time travel story, I sort of needed the info.

And thankfully, I got a response!

Superman group editor Paul Kaminski confirmed that this time travel jaunt does indeed take place about 5 years prior to Krypton's destruction. 

This helps me plant a continuity stake in the ground! 

Thanks to Kaminsky for helping me (and other fans) process the events!

Review: Supergirl #17

Supergirl #17 came out this week, the 5th chapter in the Kingdom Of Zod event, and the first on this side plot of a time trip back to Krypton. I have had a bit of a hard time understanding what Zod was hoping to accomplish with his 'growing Kryptonite' plot. But things changed last issue with Zod being killed by Ursa. Then Ursa, Kara, and young Clark all hopped a time bubble to try and stop Krypton from exploding. That is one left turn.

And with so much time spent on Krypton, the Earth story of the growing K is a bit in the background and I didn't mind that!

Sophie Campbell makes a meal out of the side trip showing us how Kara is approaching the whole thing. I like the maturity Supergirl shows, recognizing that despite her love for her world she cannot interfere with the timeline. In fact, that worry about changing things seems to overwhelm her thoughts. How can she stop Ursa, interact on the planet, and not change things. We get a lot of Kara this issue which doesn't always happen in this series and the full cast. I was glad to get this deep dive into our title hero's psyche.

Of course, this being a time travel story you have to think hard or not think at all. If this trip is now in the timeline, maybe anything they did IS the timeline and not disrupting it. Hmmm ...

The art is mix of Joe Quinones and Bruno Frenda. Both give us wonderful renditions of Supergirl, leaning into the emotions she is feeling being back on Krypton. There is one moment that could have used a bit more poignancy but things move pretty fast here.

On to the issue.

Review: Superman #41

Superman #41 came out this week, the next chapter in the Kingdom of Zod crossover. This is a 9-parter and this is chapter 4 so we are basically at the halfway mark. And this is quite an issue as it takes a hard ... and I mean HARD ... left turn taking this story to two places I was not expecting.

I will say that this whole arc is building off of the  Kneel Before Zod mini-series from 2 years ago. (All those issues are reviewed here at that link so feel free to dive in!) I will remind you that mini-series was supposed to be 12 issues but was cut by DC to 9, so I wonder if some of this plot was supposed to be touched on or even begun there. Also, as pointed out by friend Mart Gray, the opening pages which fill in what happened in that mini are direct lifts from that book. (Hope writer Joe Casey and artist Dan McDaid are getting some compensation.) In that book, I was surprised by how beaten down Zod was initially and how domineering Ursa was. Suffice it to say, we see that play out here.

I will also say that one of my biggest peeves about this whole story is the 'Kryptonite everywhere' aspect when it seems to have little or no impact on the action. Our Kryptonian heroes seem more irritated by being surrounded by Green K than in agony. So I decided to read this issue ignoring the Green K conundrum and I found that it reads better that way. But it seems odd that I can ignore the driving plot element. And I wonder if we will ever learn how Zod got that massive Green K meteor, altered it, covered it in intertron, and sent it on its way.

But enough backstory, Joshua Williamson and Eddy Barrows give us the best chapter of this arc. We get decent action. We get some plot progression. We get to see Superman in action. And we get two ... no three ... major developments and plot twists. I don't know if those new threads will pay off but I am more interested in them than the growing Green K stuff. 

On to the details.

Review: Superman Unlimited #16

Superman Unlimited #16 came out this week, chapter three in the Kingdom of Zod storyline. We are one third done and I don't know if I quite grasp this whole plotline. But this was a classic middle chapter, nudging the story along and making sure everyone knows what is going on. It does have a wonderful moment in the middle with Supergirl and Superboy. But otherwise, this felt a bit like treading water.

Most importantly for me, we at least heard that all this Kryptonite is affecting our Kryptonian characters. But I don't know if it is enough for me to be happy. We have seen Kryptonians buckle in pain when near a small piece of Kryptonite in the past. How can they be flying around a city made of Green K and just complain a little about how it feels. Sigh. I'll get past this ... maybe.

Dan Slott captures the voice of all the characters here. I like his Kara. I like his young Superboy. I like his Jon Kent. But he doesn't have too much to do here.

Rachael Stott is on art this issue and she brings a sort of breathy flair to the issue. I think the action sequences flow. But her art is perfect for that Supergirl/Superboy moment in the middle. I really liked that section, the highpoint of the book for me.

But I still don't quite understand what is going on in this story. Why would Zod think unleashing a Green K tsunami on Earth be good for him?

On to the book.

Review: Action Comics #1101

The first two parts of the Kingdom of Zod event came out last week. Action Comics #1101 is the second chapter and picks up where Action Comics #1100 ended with the return of Superman while sliding into the Zod arc.

Last week I reviewed Supergirl #16 and talked about how I find the Zod plot confusing right now. And I don't know if this chapter makes any of it clearer. Zod has a Green K variant that is expanding over the Earth. It is causing a plague that is harming humans. It is still deadly to Kryptonians. Why would Zod want any of this? Why is he not ill from the effects of the Green K in some way? How did he get this huge Green K meteor, cover it in inertron, and move forward? So far I have too many questions.

We do get great scenes in this book where Lois is using her journalism skills to get Zod to reveal his inner thoughts. I love the Lois in this book. But I don't know if the answers he gives make much sense either. No surprise that writer Mark Waid writes a great Lois and Superman Family. But I am still confused.

The art is by Montos who is relatively new to me. I have seen his stuff in Green Lantern and I like his work here. It has a breathy sort of style. He uses shadows incredibly well. The fight sequences are rendered well. 

But we are two chapters in and I am confused. On to the book. 

Review: Supergirl #16

Supergirl #16 came out this week, the first chapter in the Kingdom of Zod crossover. While I am thrilled that the opening chapter is in the Supergirl book, perhaps bringing more eyes to the title, I have to say this story starts off a bit rushed and confusing. 

I don't know if I quite understand what Zod is trying to accomplish here. I don't know why he isn't impacted by a ton of Green K around him. But that is more a commentary on the overall story. Let's concentrate on this issue. 

Sophie Campbell does a solid job showing how Kara is trying to grow into her role of Heir to the House of El. How Kara is trying to be a leader for the El family in Superman's absence. But it isn't going to be an easy transition so seeing Kara doing her best to keep the team together on a dangerous mission into El Caldero is great characterization for our title hero. This is a Super-event so there are plenty of other characters here but Campbell really has Supergirl in the spotlight.

The art is a mix between Joe Quinones and Paolo Villanelli. The styles are quite different with Quinones being a more smooth style and Villanelli being more thin-lined, angular, and a bit rougher. The result can feel a bit jarring and I don't know if that is the best way to start an event either.

I honestly hope I understand Zod's plan at some point. But I don't yet. On to the issue.