Wednesday, November 12, 2008

Bullet Points And Reviews

Just want to do some quick house-keeping on a few brief items.

Then to the comic book store. Action Comics #871 is out today; review should be up before the weekend.


Reign in Hell #4: The bottom line is 'no Linda Danvers'.

As for the rest of the story, the forces of Hell and the forces of Purgatory continue their war in the Underworld. Purgatory seems to be routing Neron's forces until a counter-attack cuts off a portion of Blaze's army. Still, the Purgatory forces are able to release a prisoner of Hell in hopes he will join their side. The prisoner? Lobo.

I have to say, DC made something of a big deal that Linda Danvers was going to be in this mini. In fact, she is the only reason I am buying it. And other than 2 pages in issue one, we haven't seen her or heard her mentioned. The plot seems to be spinning it's wheels a bit too. Disheartening.

Overall grade: C

Adventure Comics Special Featuring the Guardian:

This was an interesting issue filling in some of the back story of the governments projects to fight Superman, including cloning of the Guardian as a hybrid of Jim Harper (the original Guardian) and Paul Kirk (an early version of Manhunter). It also included a captured Tellus from the late 80's Legion! It also progressed Jimmy Olson's storyline where he is more becoming 'Mr. Action' the reporter rather than coffee gopher.

No Superman or Supergirl in sight but still an intriguing chapter in New Krypton.

At the very least it was nice to see Adventure Comics again. Supergirl had a nice solo run in the title in the late 60's through the early 70's.

Overall grade: B


Smallville: Bloodline ratings:

As reported on the Superman Homepage, the CW reports that Kara's return in last night's "Bloodline" episode hit season highs last night in adults 18-34 (1.9/6), adults 18-49 (1.9/5) and total viewers (4.5mil). IN FACT, it was the highest rated and most watched episode of the show in nearly a year (since 11/15/07).

This was mentioned in the Smallville review thread posts but thought it warranted it's own little blurb in the main blog. I hope it will not go unnoticed by the CW that Kara's return prompted more viewers to the show than has been seen recently. Maybe that Kara spin-off isn't such a bad idea. At the very least, I hope they bring her back for the season finale. And maybe in uniform?

And maybe I am biased, but wasn't Kara just a more dynamic character in her brief shining moments than Clark has been in about 3 seasons?


Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom #1

This was posted by Jimmy Palmiotti on Geoff John's Comic Bloc Forums:

this is and was always planned as a stand alone story out of continuity. its been done for a while on our end and just finished by phil noto, so dc jumped to put it out.

personally it should have been a trade book out of the gate, but all that said, its a stand alone that has nothing to do with the regular books. It was made for the fans of these characters and fans of phil's work...so any support is appreciated.

thanks. jimmy

Well I guess that settles the 'where in continuity' question. It is out of continuity. I don't know if that makes my reaction to the issue better or worse. Anyways, I will be in for the rest of the mini and I'll keep the reviews coming.

Monday, November 10, 2008

Wizard 206: Interview With the Super-teams


It didn't even make the cover text, but inside this month's Wizard was a group interview with the writers of the 3 super-titles: Geoff Johns, James Robinson, and Sterling Gates. The topic was New Krypton.


Here are a few of the key points, although I would recommend reading the whole interview if possible.


Wizard: How does Pa Kent's death affect his (Superman's) relationships with Kara and Lois?
Gates: In regards to Supergirl, she shares the joy of Kandor's return and the return of her people, and to her, what he's experiencing, she already felt when she lost her parents and was sent to Earth. I think it's going to be an identification point for the two of them to latch onto each other emotionally.

It is interesting that Superman and Supergirl are having reverse fortunes here. Superman lost his father. Supergirl regains hers.

However, she already went through a grieving period about that loss, and so she might be a source of strength and wisdom for him. Of course, we still need to figure out what all the different Zor-El memories mean. Maybe she would not totally mourn the loss of the 'Kill Kal-El' maniac.

Wizard: We see that Supergirl takes on a secret identity, and we know the same happens for Atlas.What does a secret identity mean for you, and why use them:
Johns: These guys - Atlas, Superman, Supergirl - they aren't human. They're these larger than life figures trying to find their place among humanity. I think exploring that through secret identity is where you get a lot of the story and drive of these characters.
Gates: She (Supergirl) has gone so long with being a Kryptonian character. Giving her a secret identity is important to help her understand and be a part of the human race.

The arguments for and against a secret identity have all been heard. I tend to side with Gates on this one. Supergirl seemed so lost in her title, a stranger in a strange land. Even in the Puckett line, where the lengths she went to save Thomas were noble but out of touch.

I think 'Linda Lang' will be a step forward for Kara in figuring out not only why she should stay on Earth but also why she would. To be honest, the universe is open to her. There has to be a hook for her to want to stay Earth-bound. And I think it needs to be more than Superman being her long lost cousin. By connecting to humanity in this basic way, I think she will want to stay.

Of course, that is assuming that New Krypton and her parents eventually end up going away.


Wizard: We also see Lana Lang taking Supergirl under her wing.
Gates: She's going to be playing the role of Supergirl's aunt.


I wonder if she is still living with Lana despite Kandor being re-grown. Doesn't make much sense. You think she would want to re-connect with her family.

Robinson: Plus, without saying who, Sterling is working on a truly wonderful Supergirl rogue's gallery that I think will further re-enliven Supergirl and make her feel more an important and intrinsic part of the DC Universe.
Gates: I think it's improtant for heroes to be partially defined by their villains and their quality of villains. and I wanted to build a world for Supergirl that crosses over in some ways with Superman but gives her her own villains to face and defeat.

Ahh ... the rogue's gallery. I like how the creators see a rogue's gallery havign 2 purposes: defining Supergirl within the universe and defining Supergirl herself. Let's face it the Joker and Two-Face work best as Batman foils, given the idealogic nature of their madness.

I am excited to see who gets added outside of Reactron. Any guesses people?



Wizard: What's the relationship like between Lana and Supergirl?
Gates: I actually really like the show called "Gilmore Girls." Yeah, yeah,yeah. Ha-ha-ha. But the relationship between the nither and daughter on the show is this friendly mentor style relationship. S0, I wanted to build this very strong, very light, very intense mentor relationship between Lana and Supergirl.

You know it's funny to admit it, but I also liked Gilmore Girls. The relationship between Lorelai and Rory was one of both friendship and mentoring. So I will be interested to see how that plays out in the title. Lana has gone through enough in the 'super' world to be able to provide wisdom in a nurturing way.

I wonder if there will be as many pop culture references in the Kara/Lana dialogue as their was on the show.




Wizard: What can you say about Zor-El and Alura?
Johns: They're both the leaders of Kandor at this point. Zor-El is like the heart and Alura is the mind.
Gates: All Supergirl wanted since she came to Earth was to go back to how things were on Krypton. When Kandor shows up and her parents show up, it's the happiest thing she could have ever wished for.

We keep hearing that all the versions of Zor-El, and all of Kara's memories will be answered in a way that makes perfect sense. I hope so, if only to erase the versions that make no sense. I get the sense that in the end, it might not be the happiest thing for Kara that her parents returned.

You can see the dyamic of heart/mind in the scenes with Zor-El and Alura. Zor-El just seems happy to be out of the bottle, deferred to the President, and call the planet Earth. Alura seems more cool and disconnected. Earth is obviously New Krypton given there superiority.

Wizard: How does the crossover work thematically from book to book?
Johns: Every title will continue into one another, but at the same time, you'll really see a focus on the inidividual titles - certain characters will get spotlighted. Supergirl obviously focuses on her and her past and her parents. Action focuses on the aftermath of Brainiac and Pa Kent and Kandor.

I do like that each title will retain its own focus despite being part of the bigger story. Let's face it, many of us were looking forward to the Gates/Igle run for a while. I did not want their ideas to be derailed by being part of a mega-crossover. I like that the Supergirl title will focus on her character and how she is dealing with Kandor.




Wizard: Are there any other specific Kryptonians that get spotlighted?
Johns: You have a new Nightwing and Flamebird. And a new Superwoman as well. We really wanted to get characters instantly recognized, because you start throwing out Kryptonian names and your eyes glaze over.

I know that folks have jumped on the Thara Ak-Var as Flamebird. But she seemed so militaristic in her short scene that I doubt she would become a masked vigilante. Plus, the hair length and color are all wrong unless she is donning a wig or using a Kryptonian comb that can change her hair color to red.

I do wonder if they will have some connection to the Superman family, as Van-Zee was in the past.

Wizard: Superwoman, aka Kristen Wells. Anything on that one?
Gates: Not at all.

I still say Superwoman ends up being an evil clone of Kara. It sounds so trite when I write it, but I am going with it.

Anyways, I have loved the New Krypton storyline so far and it sounds like the writers have it tight and polished.

Saturday, November 8, 2008

Smallville:Bloodlines and Laura Vandervoort's TV Guide interview


Smallville:Bloodlines aired on Thursday, marking the return of Laura Vandervoort's Kara to the show, at least for one episode.

Below find a link for an interview she did in TV Guide about her return. I included the most pertinent questions here.


TVGuide.com: Where in the universe has Kara been?
Laura Vandervoort: She's been in the Phantom Zone — and apparently Smallville had forgotten that, because no one has mentioned her since the season started. [Laughs]

It is true. We have had no mention of her so far this season. It's as though they wanted people to just forget she was ever on the show.

TVGuide.com: Is she any worse for the wear?
Vandervoort: Yeah. Time passes by faster in the Phantom Zone, but when Clark finds her she's a little bit messed up in the head. She's on-edge and not quite herself.

TVGuide.com: What, overall, is the "Bloodline" episode about?
Vandervoort: It's about Clark and Kara coming together as a family, but perhaps deciding that they need to not be in the same place to best help the world. There's a little line at the end of the episode about how they'll always be close to each other's hearts and be family, no matter what.

TVGuide.com: Is this where Kara urges Clark to don some tights already?
Vandervoort: I don't think you're ever going to see him in tights. [Laughs]

TVGuide.com: Does she at least give him that much-needed flying lesson...?
Vandervoort: Um, no. There was that one episode last season where she attempted to teach him and it didn't work out, so I don't think she'll be the one to do it.

TVGuide.com: Do you have scenes with anyone outside of Tom Welling?
Vandervoort: I have scenes with Erica [Durance, Lois], but they don't last too long, because I knock her out — mistakenly! And I have a brief scene with Allison [Mack, Chloe].

TVGuide.com: Does Kara suspect that, as rumored, Chloe has been possessed by Brainiac?Vandervoort: No, she doesn't. Kara doesn't talk about Brainiac at all.

TVGuide.com: Were you glad to get the call to make this return appearance?
Vandervoort: Yeah! When they told me last season they had kind of run out of storylines for me and they needed to focus on Clark, I was upset because in my mind I was planning to be back for another season. And there was also the [once-rumored Supergirl] spin-off thing. I took it personally and said to the producers, "Look, is there something I could have done better?" They said, "We want you all the time on the show." But they've got to focus on Clark and Lois, and having another superhero around who could fly, while Clark can't, wouldn't work out.

We have talked about it on this blog a bunch. They ran outof storylines because she was more heroic and dynamic than Clark and you can't have that on this show. Too bad, sounds like she enjoyed her time.

And I can only imagine how good the spin-off series would have been.



As for the episode itself ... well ... it could have been worse. And for a second there I feared disaster.

Clark and Lois find themselves trasported into the Phantom Zone by the Kryptonian blue crystal. It is unclear exactly why the crystal teleported them there, I guess that is one of those plot points that we just need to accept.

Once there, they run into Kara who has been fighting to survive since her imprisonment. Interestingly enough, there is a way out for her, a back door built by Zor-El. Exactly why Zor-El would build an escape route from the Phantom Zone that can only be triggered by his daughter is also a bit strange. Nevertheless, it is there ... but Kara has not used it for fear that 'Zoners', the spirits of the prisoners there, could escape with her. (Apparently this happened once already during a season I was not watching.) At least that is noble of Kara to be thinking of Earth's safety more than her own.

Clark, amazingly, tells Kara that he will defend the portal while Lois and Kara escape. Wow! He actually was going to let Kara escape. Lois is able to escape but not before a zoner escapes with her. And before Kara can leave a large rock falls on her, pinning her legs. Realizing she is dying, she begs Clark to leave her.

How many of us were worried right here that she was going to die right there, another nameless corpse in the zone? I'm raising my hand. That would have been disastrous.

Luckily, Chloe is able to tap into her Brainiac powers, reactivate the crystal, and get both Clark and Kara out of there.

It's a good thing too! Lois has been possessed by Zod's wife Faora (a nice nod to Silver Age Phantom Zone woman villain Faora Hu-ul) and has Kryptonian powers now. She is looking for her son .. an amalgam of the best Kryptonian genes, both animal and human, something powerful and unbeatable ... and that person is Davis, the EMT driver who has been on the show this month and who becomes Doomsday later on.

Lois gets depossessed and forgets most of what happened. Davis begins to realize his powers. But most importantly Kara lived! She tells Clark she is leaving Earth to try to find Kandor (an odd 'show imitates comics' coincidence). We last see her flying off into deep space.

So, throughout the show Kara is shown trying to do the right thing. Clark actually tries to do the right thing and talks about how Kara is his family and he needs her (funny how it took 8 episodes to hear it). And Kara actually leaves with a pretty good mission in mind. I have to admit it. This episode was better than I thought it would be.

Overall grade: B

Thursday, November 6, 2008

Review: Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom #1


This is a long post, so bear with me.

I wrote just yesterday about my optimism for the Palmiotti/Gray/Noto Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom miniseries. It was optimism knowing that there is always a chance that optimism can melt away to disappointment.

This is the first issue of a 5 issue mini, so I have only read a small portion of the whole story. Still, I have to say I was pretty disappointed here.


The story opens on Apokolips where we meet Maelstrom. Maelstrom is not a Female Fury in training. She is not a warrior or even in the military. No, she is down among the laborers but she has aspirations far away from that lowly status. She wants to be Darkseid's bride. She does not just serve Darkseid, she loves him and she is willing to do anything to get his notice. That includes stealing contraband Boom Tube technology and heading to Earth. Maybe if she brings Superman's head on a platter, Darkseid will love her back.

Now there is some good plot possibilities here. Just how often do people dream on Apokolips? How does one advance their status there? Are you born in a caste that you die in ... or can you move forward? We know Apokolips is a bleak place where people are in the elite or a slave. But I can't recall reading a story from the point of view of a slave who wants more on Apokolips rather than freedom. So this was a good start, an original character with an interesting point of view.

Maelstrom arrives in Metropolis during a week when Superman is away on a mission in space. He put Supergirl in charge and she initially complains of a slow week of action until something gets her attention.

Yep, nothing like a bunch of cars being thrown into the air to get a super-hero's attention. Perhaps best done in the classic Miracleman #15, but more recently seen in Supreme Power, it is an effective method of bringing the heroes to you or delaying them as you escape.


Unfortunately for Supergirl fans, what we then get is a 7 straight pages of Kara being tossed around like a rag doll and beaten like a heavy bag. First the dreaded 'swing you around by your hair into a bunch of stuff' technique. Then Supergirl gets punted into a skyscraper.


She recovers just in time to see Maelstrom upend a whole hospital building ... the whole hospital!!!! That is some prestigious strength there. Supergirl can only watch as the building crumbles scattering people everywhere .... injuring most, killing some.

Flying to the rescue and to confront Maelstrom, Supergirl is quickly dispatched. Maelstrom grabs her by the face and buries her into the pavement. Maelstrom calls Supergirl 'weak and useless' and is about to kill her when Superman shows up to save the day.


3 pages later, Maelstrom is soundly defeated and sent back to where she came from.


Supergirl is able to barely rouse herself and thankfully her first thoughts are for the injured people. Superman casually tells her he has already saved the survivors. She then passes out again.

Okay, I have to admit I cringed a lot here ... but let me finish the issue and then I'll get into my review.

Cut to 3 days later with Kara sulking on the moon. Superman gives her another pep talk, one we have seen him give this Kara a handful of times already.

"You're not the first to fail," he says ... sort of like the 'it's okay to be scared' line from Action Comics or the 'you can't save everyone' lines from Puckett's 'Saving Thomas' story.


Supergirl begins crying, telling him this was more than failure, it was catastrophe. She even confides about her 'self-doubt'.


Superman tells Supergirl that he feels he is to blame because he threw her into a life of hero-ing without overseeing her training himself. He should have taught her how to use her powers himself. And he plans on doing it. They are going away from Earth for a week to train.

He tells Kara that he asked Power Girl to watch over Metropolis while they are gone. That's a real nice way to help her self-doubt. If I was Supergirl this is how I would have heard that: "Hey Kara, you failed keeping my city safe ... so while we are gone I put someone in charge I can trust, your better trained and more discipined clone from another Earth. I always liked her better."



Despondent, Supergirl tells Superman to leave her alone. Put he puts down his foot saying whether she likes it or not, he is taking her with him.

The issue ends with Maelstrom being re-educated by Granny Goodness. I guess we are supposed to look at Supergirl and Maelstrom as two sides of the same coin. Both are young and want to improve their standing in life; both are in the shadow of someone bigger than life. And both are going to need to train/survive to reach their goals.

Whew ....

First off let me say that I absolutely loved the art work on the issue.

Now, the first thing I tried to do after reading this issue was figure out where I was going to put it in continuity. It can't be now because I don't think the 'current' Kara would act this way. Supergirl seems like such a newcomer here that it would need to be early on. The fact that Superman is talking about her training puts it very early.


So for me, I am going to wedge this after issue #5 but before the Candor arc. This storyline seems to best fit in the year we missed when we move 'One Year Later'.

If we are talking about that Kara maybe I can understand some of her reactions a little better. She just dealt with the evil persona manifesting itself. She was recently under Darkseid's thrall. And she was new to Earth and heroing as a whole. So maybe ... maybe ... I can understand her emotions here. And I certainly liked the fact that when she awoke her first thoughts were to save the people, not rage over the defeat or sadness about the failure. But to see her crying, to hear her lamenting her abilities, to see her sulking on the moon ... that seems too extreme for this character.

And I also find it very unsettling that she was defeated so soundly by Maelstrom. Kara was trained by the Amazons in the ways of combat and did have some adventures prior to this. And around that time we were seeing a Kara who was giving the Trinity a run for the money. To see her trounced by a character who's only experience is the hard life on Apokolips also seems a bit out of touch here. Maelstrom is no Female Fury but she gives Kara a beating. This is only made worse by the fact that Superman basically defeats her by putting her in a bear hug.

I have said it before, writing Supergirl is a tricky business. I do not envy the writers. It is hard to please Supergirl's fans. We want her to be strong both physically and emotionally ... but we want a hint of vulnerability. We don't want her to be infallible; we want to see her succeed and fail, learn and grow. But we don't want her to constantly fail or seem weak.

Superman can be a great catalyst in Supergirl stories but he can make things trickier. Supergirl fans want Superman to be in her life, and we don't mind him being a role model. But I don't think we want him to be a over-protective father figure nor do we want him to always outclass her. At least not all the time.

So to see Kara beaten, defeated, saved by Superman, crying in self-pity, and being pulled from the doldrums by Superman ... it was a bit too much of the things I don't necessarily like to see.

I am going to call this an early adventure of Supergirl. There is great potential in this story. I realize that this is just the beginning of this arc and maybe we see a stronger Kara the next 4 issues. I certainly hope so. Because I don't think she was treated well in this issue.

Overall grade: C-

Wednesday, November 5, 2008

Phil Noto on Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom


The Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom mini-series' first issue gets released today and I, for one, am pretty intrigued to read it. The story is written by Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray and drawn by Phil Noto, a favorite artist of mine.

Newsarama recently interviewed Noto about the mini. Here is the link (http://www.newsarama.com/comics/110805-Maelstrom-Noto.html ).

Below are some of the parts that struck me as most interesting, with my comments added.

Newsarama: Good to talk to you, Phil. Let's get right into it –Superman and Supergirl – are these characters you wanted to tackle or is it a gig that just came along?

Phil Noto: After making a career out of spy girl, film noir, and western comics, I wanted to try something different and do a full on superhero book. Dan Didio suggested Superman and Supergirl and I couldn't be happier. I love the characters. After talking with Jimmy and Justin, this is the miniseries we came up with.


I think if an artist is excited about the project, it shows. Noto would not be the first on my list for interiors of a superhero book, but I absolutely love his covers. He did a great run on Birds of Prey which included some more classic super-hero-y covers., including this one of Power Girl. The commissions I have seen of super-heroes are also phenomenal. And his interiors on things like Jonah Hex, Infinite Horizon, Danger Girl are always slick. So I am pretty excited to see his interiors here.

And no ... I won't bore you with posting my Noto Supergirl commission again.

NRAMA:Your style is not like anyone else’s in the business...what’s your art background?

PN: I went to art school for illustration. Back then I never thought of doing any kind of comic art. I was, however, a big fan of Kent Williams and George Pratt, who were definitely comic artists/illustrators. I was also very influenced by the guys who did all the book covers and advertising art in the 50's and 60's, like Robert McGinnis, Bob Peak, and Coby Whitmore.

You can totally see the 50's ad influence in his art on many covers, but some more than others. I love this Birds of Prey cover, which looks like a airline ad from an old Saturday Evening Post. And yet, it works here with Black Canary. It is such a unique style ... eye catching. And when there are hundreds of books on the shelf competing for attention, this stands out.


NRAMA: Moving on, we know you worked with Jimmy on Beautiful Killer and New West in the past and Jimmy with Justin on Jonah Hex. Their work stands out from a lot of the writers in comics today, why do you think that is? What’s the appeal to you personally?

PN: I love working with those guys. I think the great thing about their writing is the combination of action and humor they create within a story. When I first get the script from them , it's like reading a great screenplay. The pacing of the stories are great and they always make even the secondary characters interesting as evidenced in the Jonah Hex books.


I loved the Palmiotti/Gray/Noto issues on Jonah Hex, especially the Tallulah Black issues. She was such a strong character. I hope she makes another appearance in that book at some point.



NRAMA: In this book Superman/Supergirl: Maelstrom, you're drawing some iconic characters that we’ve seen in countless stories so what’s different about this one?

PN: I think this a great example of the relationship between Superman and Supergirl. Superman , because of the red sun, isn't invincible and I think that makes for an interesting role reversal in which Supergirl has to be the protector, somewhat.

Given that the last time I read a Palmiotti Supergirl she was reluctant to stop dancing and save people, this already sounds like a step in the right direction. I think that one frequent complaint about the Supergirl character is that she is always in Superman's shadow, always deferring to him. So to hear she is protecting him is great.


NRAMA: In the script, are there design or story elements that grabbed you right away as something you really wanted to illustrate?

PN: I was excited to come up with a look for them out of the capes. They're essentially a wearing what could be considered Kryptonian survival suits. The aliens that they encounter were a lot of fun to draw also. Certainly the first time I've been able to create something like them in a comic.

The picture above is the cover of Superman/Supergirl:Maelstrom #3. Look at Kara kicking some butt! The 'survival suits' are kind of interesting. The first thing I thought of was the 'stillsuits' in David Lynch's Dune.

Looks like Noto was able to stretch his artistic legs a bit here.


NRAMA: Do you have a favorite artist? Or artists that inspire you?

PN: Like I said before, I've been inspired and influenced by the paperback illustrators of the 50's and 60's. In terms of comic artists , I'm a big fan of Alex Toth, Mike Mignola, Bill Sienkiewicz, Adam Hughes, Darwyn Cooke, Ashley Wood, Walt Simonson, Howard Chaykin, Art Adams, J. Scott Campbell and countless others.


Along with the 'advertising' look, I like the 'paperback' look as well. Doesn't this Birds of Prey cover look like an old pulp dime novel. Again, it is pretty striking for a comic cover.

And he names a bunch of my favorite artists amongst his favorites - especially Toth, Simonson, Adams, and Chaykin.

While everything I have read about the mini sounds great, I am not without some worries.

Originally scheduled as a Superman:Confidential arc, it was decided to release it as a mini and a stand alone story. It includes Darkseid and the New Gods and frankly I am a bit weary of the Fourth World right now. Also, as the Fourth World characters are dead or resurrected in human form right now, I think we will all have to squeeze this into continuity wherever it most easily fits.

In some ways this is concerning to me. So much has been done recently to rehabilitate the Kara character (and I include the Kelley Puckett run on her title), that I hope the continuity anchor here is not back to the 'Kill Kal-El' Joe Kelly issues. I already had to relive that a bit in the recent Brave and Bold issues. I *do not* want to go back there.


And as said above, Supergirl #12 was not a great portrayal of Kara. I hope that the Palmiotti/Gray team does not have her act like a disinterested rave girl again.

I don't think that will be the case. I will review the first issue soon.

Tuesday, November 4, 2008

Scott Wegener Commission


The Boston Comic-con was on Sunday and, as usual, it was a fun time. The guests of honor were Bernie Wrightson (Swamp Thing fame) and Peter Laird (TMNT fame). But there were plenty of other artists there, including one of my new favorites Scott Wegener.

I was able to get this great commission of Supergirl, striking a heroic and friendly pose with Wegener's signature character, Atomic Robo. What a fun commission ... my first 2 character commission with Kara.


I briefly talked about Atomic Robo on this blog before. It is a great comic produced by Red 5 comics, written by Brian Clevinger, and primarily drawn by Wegener.

Robo is a sentient robot brought to life by Nikola Tesla in the 20's and granted citizenship by the US government during WW2. The stories in the first mini-series ranged from some World War 2 combat missions, to the Korean War, to stranger adventures involving walking pyramids and giant ants, etc.

Robo works with 'Action Scientists' and they are called in to face these crazy threats. The first mini-series was great fun and reminded me of times when comics did not need an undercurrent of grimness. The adventures are fun with outright humor. It has a feel of Indiana Jones and early sci-fi. The comic was good enough to be nominated for an Eisner Award last year for 'Best Limited Series'.


The second mini-series is titled 'Dogs of War' and takes place again in WW2, as Robo helps the army stop some experimental German walking tanks.

Clevinger's plots are great and his dialogue is right on the money. When it needs to be serious, it is serious. You can't have a beachhead invasion be all fun and games. But when it needs some humor, that's there too.

Wegener has a pretty distinct style; I get a hint of early Ted McKeever sometimes.

Robo is one of the titles I just really look forward to each month. The first mini was collected in a trade and available on-line. As for the 'Dogs of War', I highly recommend it. Definitely look for it in your local comic book store or ask for it if you don't see it. It is really a wonderful comic.

And I just love that commission. It is a really nice addition to my collection.

Monday, November 3, 2008

Middleton Line Work

I have to say that so far I have been completely enamored of the Joshua Middleton Supergirl covers. They are very stylish, just the perfect tinge of japanese manga without being over the top.

So I was happy to see him share the pencil/ink work of the covers on issues 34 and 37 on his blog. Here is the link: http://joshuamiddleton.blogspot.com/2008/11/supergirl-lines.html

I enjoy any time an artist can share the creative process. From thumbnail to pencils to final cover, I enjoy watching the evolution of a particular piece. This was no different.

You can see how clean this pencil work is before the coloring and shading occurs. This is pretty fine line work here, but without much added to convey depth, texture, or dimension. That was added via the coloring process as we see the light source from the left casting shadows as the two burst from the printed page.


Compare that to the cover of Supergirl #37.

Much more shading has been added here, with pencils doing more of the work to detail Superwoman's musculature, the flow of her cape, etc. from the light source below.

This cover really works for me. For one, I think Middleton does a great job of giving her a feeling of movement and action despite this being a simple a figure drawing with no background or other reference points. When the 're-entry sparks' of her boots are added in the coloring process, you really have a dynamic piece.

I am impressed that Middleton is able to subtly change styles like this and pull of both covers so wonderfully. If the three Supergirl covers we have seen are an indication, I hope he has a long run with the title.