Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Review: Supergirl #19 (v8)


Hello all! I am back from vacation and have to catch up on reviews starting with Supergirl #19. 

'The Ego Death of Supergirl' was written and drawn by Sophie Campbell and highlighted some of the concerns I have had about this title at times. Ego Death is a true term associated with self-surrender and transition and here it means Kara getting used to life as a non-powered being. Reactron has used Gold K on her and now there may not be a way to come back. Who is she without her powers? Is she still Supergirl?

The idea is interesting and might be a good way to delve into the character and her psyche. But instead this Supergirl seems to roll with it, very quickly thinking of an exciting life as a 'normal' girl, a life Nightflame says Kara has pined for. Hmmm ...

Then the over-stuffed supporting cast takes over as all the other members of the Super Force decide to weigh in on who should take up the title of Supergirl. In particular, Matrix and Nightflame come to blows about it. I have bemoaned the lack of a supporting cast in more recent Supergirl books. Here there are just so many that Kara takes a bit of a backseat sometime. Trust me, I am thrilled to see Matrix again and I love how Campbell draws her. But this feels more like a Legion of Super-Heroes book right now.

I shouldn't be surprised that ThunderGirl, perhaps the least experienced member of the bunch gets chosen to be Supergirl. She immediately is fantastic at the job. There could be some stories of ThunderGirl not wanting the title. Or not doing well at it. But we don't see that here. She just steps in perfectly.

I like Supergirl in this book. And I have enjoyed this title a lot. But I don't read Supergirl to read about a depowered Kara and ThunderGirl wearing the S-shield. I read Supergirl to read the adventures of Supergirl. Right now, that is not what this book is. I can't imagine this stays the long term status quo. I am sure that Lena (with Superman) will figure out a cure for Gold K depowering, but only a one time cure since we can't have that cure out there forever. 

On to the book.


We start out with the SuperForce defending Supergirl against Reactron who decides there are too many super-powered beings in the Fortress to duke it out. He takes off.

I love seeing Matrix Supergirl again in the blue shirt/red skirt combo. My personal fave.

And love seeing the effect of the gold K sort of seeping out of Kara. Amazing.


The next few pages are strong storytelling.

Everyone starts to talk about what is going to happen next in Kara's life. This includes, thankfully, Superman who is on the monitor talking about working hard to reverse the process. 

Initially Kara seems to be reeling. She is still Supergirl ... or is she. She lived without powers more than with. But can she be the Heir to the House of El. But can she still be that?

Campbell does a great job showing the emotions roiling here.


Nightflame assumes she will be Supergirl. She has Kara's memories and is a sort of dark extension of Supergirl. (I still don't know why Nightflame exists externally and would be welcomed on the team.)

Matrix thinks it should be her. She filled in before and has experience. (I'd actually like to read that book.)

But Kara really seems to be reeling. Suddenly, it seems to click that she could go back to school and become a social worker helping the unhoused or hungry. Yes, heroic and I can see her doing that. But she seems to just get over losing her powers very quickly. This should be hitting her harder. She fights as Supergirl to protect people from suffering like she did. She loves that job. 


As I said, the pages of this discussion about who should be Supergirl and what is Kara going to do are well done. Campbell keeps filling the panels with more and more word balloons as everyone is talking over each other, sometimes with some balloons literally being partly over others to show how raucous things are getting. It is fantastic comic work where art and words complement each other.

Matrix and Nightflame actually fight over who will be Supergirl until ThunderGirl stops them.

ThunderGirl asks Kara if our titular hero will be okay. That moment of kindness strikes Kara. Maybe the best person to be Supergirl is ThunderGirl.

Now ThunderGirl has barely lived, being a cloned version of ThunderBoy. She has only been out of Kandor for a hot second. She shouldn't accept or be up to the task. But she does and she is. She is immediately great at it, getting a double page splash. All of this seems too quick and too easy. 

But I don't read Supergirl to read about ThunderGirl's adventures. 


Kara daydreams about Nightflame losing control and since Nightflame is part of Kara's psyche this makes me a little nervous.

Perhaps this is just Supergirl dealing with her inability to be help in super-heroic stuff?


I do like that the first thing a non-powered Kara does is get her hair cut. Her whole life is different. This is such a symbolic thing. Remember when in the Gates/Igle run, Kara cut her hair after the end of New Krypton. It is a sort of rebirth or reimagining of who you are. Nice!

And I assume this is Reactron talking to someone on the phone. Could we be seeing a recreation of The Council, the shady group that wanted to fight Supergirl and utilized Reactron back in The Daring New Adventure days?


Kara decides to go to Stanhope as a nonpowered student. She doesn't hear people approaching the door. She can't open the peanut butter.

Matrix (as Mae Kent) and Luna are her roommates. And they have another roommate ...Wanda  Seven ( a riff on Wanda Five from Supergirl Vol 1) and she is a journalism major who is focusing on super-hero journalism. 

There is a lot to unpack in this small scene.

Wanda might seem like a fun addition, perhaps a foil given her interests and she is living with three super-heroes. But she is ANOTHER character in this book! This book is already super-stuffed.

We also hear how everyone immediately loves the new Supergirl. Kara is thrilled everyone loves her. Too fast, too soon, too easy, too convenient.


The book ends with Kara taking on a new persona. She will be a Batman-like hero in the evenings.

I hope she calls herself Nightwing ... so Kryptonian. She looks very much like Black Canary. Hopefully we see some Kara adventures here. 

So Kara just immediately embraces a life without powers. ThunderGirl is immediately beloved as Supergirl. We add another character to a packed book. Is this a Supergirl book anymore?

I will say the art is sumptuous and those pages with the heavy discussion are wonderfully composed.

Overall grade: C+

9 comments:

Kara Lovett said...

I seem to have enjoyed this book much more than you did and it’s possible it’s my favorite single issue of the title so far. I think all your concerns are completely valid and understandable but I’m really enjoying what it seems to be setting up. With the title “Ego Death of Supergirl” my mind goes to Death of Superman and Matrix, ThunderGirl, and Nightflame taking up the role of Supergirl feels like the 4 replacement Supermen (Steel, Superboy, Eradicator, and the Cyborg). Also thank you for mentioning Wanda Five! I was almost positive Wanda Seven was a reference because it felt so familiar but I couldn’t immediately recognize it.

Anj said...

Great comment as I never even thought about the 'Reign of the Supermen' connection of people vying for the mantle.

RICK DA SILVA SANTOS said...

I am surprised you didn't comment on Mae's "space cadet" character or the fact that her civilian persona kinda looks like Linda with the brown bob haircut. Also strange that Kara has dropped her Linda Danvers persona and calling herself Kara without using her magic comb.

Anj said...

I should've commented on seeing Mae. I do love she has a PAD Linda look to her.
But it slipped by me that Kara called herself Kara. We'll have to see if that sticks.

Steve said...

Nightflame makes no sense at all and we never did get a scene setting it up. Wombat's worse. Poof! Extraneous and unnecessary character appears fully accepted by all! And why do they even need Wanda around, diluting Kara's panel space even further? If they do an issue with no Kara would anyone even notice?

Martin Gray said...

Well, you know I agree the book is too crowded, and Supergirl doesn’t do male pals, but at least Wanda is a regular human. Well, so far… she may turn out to be Wanda 7.

What are the odds of Kara finishing this college course? Id say zero.

You may know, Anthony has just interviewed Sophie Campbell for Digging For Kryptonite, that’s one to listen out for. Hopefully my question about the overstuffed cast will come up.

Steve said...

What help is if there were different locales with some of the cast of thousands so she's at A and it's these twelve and at B it's the other dozen. Oh and either explain Nightflame's physical presence and anything at all about Wombat or ditch them. It's like Wombat just entered the room and everyone just accepted them with no explanation.

Anonymous said...

Personally, I'd give Supergirl time to process her sudden un-superness with a Milly Alcockian bender (of sorts), but thats not The Sophie Campbell Way at all and so off to college Kara/Linda scampers. This supporting cast is..."extensive" but I'm not prepared...yet to call it cluttered or superfluous. In fact it's just big enough to hide a traitor. Now up until now the list for me, started and ended with Lesla Lar (depowering Supergirl is a very very very "classic Lesla move" as well as doing it from hiding) buuuut Nightflame is also acting very suspiciously (almost too suspiciously, she could be a red herring), she's another classic "depowerment practitioner" so she's down on the list too. I'll put Lena on there as well mostly on a precautionary basis she is the other big super science person on the squad and the kryptonite spectrum is a family obession after all. If you go on youtube right now, you can find more than a few racist comics "influencers" who are opposed to this with all the bile surging thru their veins, but then I doubt they read the actual floppy I think all their info comes from bots and other influencers, who are naught but a sad destructive lot. Thundergirl'a skin tone irks them to no end...me? On to the next ish sez I! :). JF

Anj said...

Thanks for continued comments here.

I continue to enjoy the book but keep hoping our hero takes a bigger piece of the stage. The most recent solicit has Bleez and Equinox showing up! Even more people!