Monday, April 11, 2011

DeConnick Interview On Supergirl


I was thrilled last week to see an interview with upcoming Supergirl writer Kelly Sue DeConnick over on Comic Book Resources. It is a great interview covering a lot of territory, not just Supergirl. I highly recommend going to read it. Here is the link: http://www.comicbookresources.com/?page=article&id=31747

One of the things that irked me in the aftermath of Sterling Gates and Jamal Igle leaving Supergirl was the complete lack of publicity around the title. The announcment that Nick Spencer was leaving the title was a line buried in a DC Source post about THUNDER Agents. There wasn't much out there at all about James Peaty or Bernard Chang grabbing the reins of that arc. And DeConnick was named a while ago as being on board for a three parter after Peaty finishes up. But there wasn't much coverage of all of that. So I was glad to be able to read so much about DeConnick's background and approach to her Supergirl story.

As always with a long interview like this one, I have cut some sections that grabbed my attention (in blue) and added some of my comments afterwards. And I'll say it again, it is worth reading the interview in its entirety.

This June, DC Comics' Supergirl " will be going to college, compliments of "Sif" and "Osborn" writer Kelly Sue DeConnick.


The second woman to ever write the Girl of Steel's self-titled series (star of the 1984 "Supergirl" movie Helen Slater lays claim to being the first), DeConnick will helm a three-issue arc, with artwork by ChrisCross and Mark Deering. Best known for her work at Marvel Comics, DeConnick will not be staying on as the long term "Supergirl" writer, leaving once her arc is complete, but that doesn't dampen her enthusiasm for leaving her mark on the life of Kara Zor-El.


"I grew up reading DC Comics; writing this book is a dream come true for me in every corny way that it could be," DeConnick told CBR News before enlightening us on what to expect from her Supergirl, her favorite fictional heroines and thoughts on the portrayal of women in the comic book industry.

So the interview opens up with us learning that DeConnick grew up reading DC Comics and considers writing Supergirl 'a dream come true'. That certainly is reassuring to me as a Supergirl fan. I want the writer to care about the character, knowing that usually leads to a solid characterization and good stories.

CBR News: Your first issue of "Supergirl" hits stores June 15. What can you tell us about your arc?
Kelly Sue DeConnick: Gifted kids have started disappearing from the area surrounding Stanhope College and one of them reappears in Metropolis, unable to tell them where she's been or why. Lois Lane and Supergirl team up to investigate.


And there's a classic villain who should look familiar to DCU readers. How's that for a taunt? Don't worry; I don't actually keep it a secret for long.

I like the sound of this plot. Certainly the fact that it is set at Stanhope College is a nice touch. And a Lois/Supergirl mystery also is a good premise. Add to that a mystery classic villain and I'm interested.

Of course, this also comes right on the heels of another mystery set at a college where Lois recruits Supergirl. Still, this one probably won't include the younger heroes of the DCU or the mystery of Alex. I think it will read fresh.

CBR: With regards to the Kara/Lois team-up, what's your take on their relationship?


KSD: In my take, Lois assumes a familiarity that's unearned and the two have to figure their relationship out. It's awkward, but there's humor and mutual respect at the base, so they get there.


CBR: Is this awkwardness because Lois is comparing Kara to Superman?


KSD: I think it's an unconscious thing rather than a deliberate slight, but yeah. She's used to level of familiarity with Superman that's not really fair to assume of Kara. And I think Kara is rightly wary of that.

So this was the thing that stuck out the most in this interview as reading wrong. "A familiarity that is unearned"? Lois and Kara have already been through the emotional mill ... from Lois chastising her for the 'Kill Kal-El' time where Supergirl stayed away, through the problems of New Krypton, and the killing of Lucy Lane. They are familiar with each other, like family.

In fact, it is hard to say that Lois overstepped her bounds asking for Supergirl's help solving a mystery when in the current arc, the one just preceding DeConnick's, Lois asked for Supergirl's help soliving a mystery.

I hope this is a small part of this arc and not a major theme because that would just seem off.

CBR: Since there's so little in the way of Post-Crisis Kara Zor-El stories, relatively speaking, is your run more influenced by the Silver Age Supergirl?


KSD: Is my Kara more influenced by the period before or after 1986? Well, after. Because, I mean, I'm not rebooting. Though my story isn't continuity hamstrung and I'd like to think that it's the kind of thing that someone who's never read a Supergirl comic before could pick up and not be lost, it's still happening in the here and now.

Well, I think that is sort of a weird question to be asked. Sure, releatively speaking there aren't many stories ... assuming the denominator is all comic stories since the 1930's.  But the current Supergirl has been around since 2004. The Supergirl title is now 5+ years old, she's been in Superman/Batman, JLA, Teen Titans, Brave and Bold, all of the New Krypton arc (2 Superman titles, 3 mini-series), and played a big part in Final Crisis. There is a big foundation to build a Supergirl arc on. She's been everywhere. So why would CBR ask it in that way?

And while I like that DeConnick wants to let new readers come to the comic and be able to understand it, I do think you need some sense of continuity, without being hamstrung. That comment in conjunction with the Lois/Kara familiarity comment makes me wonder if DeConnick has read the current title recently.

CBR: While we're talking about the past, were you a "Supergirl" fan as a kid?


KSD: Yes, comics were a big part of my life growing up -- I grew up on military bases overseas and we only got one American TV channel -- AFRTS (or A-Farts, as we called it). There are huge gaps in my pop culture knowledge base as a result. Gaps shaped like "The Brady Bunch," for instance. My friends and I gobbled up comics to make up for our lack of TV. And, as it happens, I was a DC girl. The Linda Carter "Wonder Woman" series probably had a lot to do with that, but who knows for sure?

So this really wasn't an answer to the question. Outside of the opening 'yes', I can't tell from this answer if DeConnick is a Supergirl fan. Still, the Stanhope reference (and an earlier Comet reference in another question) makes me think she is or at least has a working knowledge of Supergirl's older adventures.

CBR: So, did your experience working with Japanese comics influence the way you view and write American comics?


KSD: I think so, yes. The clearest point A to point B line can be drawn from spending years focused on polishing dialogue to writing scripts with an emphasis on dialogue. I write my dialogue first, then I break scenes down into pages and panels. I'm sure that's how I'm most comfortable.


In the "Supergirl" script, I was also more specific about fashion than I think most American comic book writers are. That, I'm certain, comes from a healthy diet of shoujo, where fashion is very much part of the appeal.

I have always talked about how I like to hear about the process behind comics. Usually I hear about it from the art point of view, how the artist goes from thumbnail layouts to roughs to finished pencils. So I loved hearing this part of DeConnick's approach to stories, writing the dialogue first. Fascinating.

And does a focus on fashion mean more Linda Lang on campus? I hope so.

CBR: You're only the second woman to write for an ongoing "Supergirl" series -- do you think you bring a fresh perspective to the character because of this? Or is gender irrelevant to the story?


KSD: As far as Kara and I go, she's a bit tricky for me to write, not because of her gender or mine, but because she's more reserved than I am as a human being. My first instincts are not hers, and if I'm not careful I run the risk of confusing "reserved" with "passive." She's not passive. She's cool, rational, cautious without being timid. As much as I think every adolescent is a boiling cauldron of dueling vulnerabilities and passions -- and Kara's no exception -- the rough start that she's gotten in life and the mantle or responsibility that she shoulders have left her more guarded, more contained than most. She's a natural leader. I'm more of a natural pain in the butt, I suspect.

'Cool, rational', 'a natural leader'. And a mention of the 'mantle of responsibility that' Supergirl shoulders. These all were nice descriptions of Supergirl and make me think that DeConnick has a good idea of the core of the character. We have all seen Supergirl also lose her cool and lash out so the 'boiling cauldron' also fits.

I think that the current Peaty run also drives home the 'natural leader' part of the character, a nice aspect of Supergirl I would love to see explored in depth.

CBR: Marvel really doesn't have an equivalent character to Kara, nor do they have a solo female series with a 60-odd year history behind her the way Supergirl does. How is it moving from Marvel to writing DC's "Supergirl?"


KSD: You know, I don't want to get into any kind of DC versus Marvel thing. I've worked at both companies; I've been treated with respect and dignity by both.


DC and Marvel have both been guilty of misusing their female characters in the past, and both are making concerted efforts correct that in the present. There's also, I think, been more thought given to potential female readership in recent history (particularly in light of the manga boom of a couple of years ago -- one that proved women and girls would not only buy and read comics, but they'd spend $8-$10 a pop), which, beyond being progressive, makes good business sense. We keep cannibalizing that same core 30-some year old white male Wednesday comic buyer and we're eventually going to fold.


Which is not to say that I want to take comics away from 30-some year old white males, or that I have anything against 30-some year old white male Wednesday comic buyers -- I don't. As it happens, I'm married to one and I think he's just about my favorite person in the universe.

Well, as a just-turned-40 year old white guy who goes to the store on Wednesday, I am all for methods or stories that will bring in new readers. As the father of the three young supergirls at home, I am always looking for good and appropriate comics that I can get them. So I welcome this.

Just in case people don't know, DeConnick's husband is Matt Fraction, a great writer whose work I always enjoy.

There is a lot more to this interview than just these questions. It is a great read. DeConnick clearly is well-read and well-versed in all media: books, films, and comics. She comes across as intelligent and witty. And she seems to have a nice understanding of Supergirl. I just hope that the surrounding material, the continuity stuff, doesn't make this seem off.

15 comments:

  1. It is indeed a great piece, apart from the 'Kara and Lois' relationship business. But she does mention that she still has time to tweak the script, so maybe she'll see this, or Supergirl Editorial will steer her in the right direction.

    Even with that qualm, I'm looking forward to seeing Kelly Sue's take on Supergirl. Obviously, she's bringing Zond back. Obviously ...

    ReplyDelete
  2. In the interview, she mentioned Kara being more restrained/conservative/etc. This still doesn't sound like my Kara. I miss David's Linda and Loeb's Kara. Looks like I'll probably be sitting this team out, much like the past four teams. Hopefully a more outspoken and confident Kara will be seen again.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The Kara you liked, Anon, seemed to me obnoxious, confused ... I like that she's grown into a confident young hero, not so quick to charge into situations. I don't think the Loeb Kara is coming back - SHE was the anomaly in 50 years of Supergirl stories, not the Supergirl as currently portrayed.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It was an interesting interview. I particularly enjoyed this line from DeConnick:

    "I'm oversimplifying, clearly -- but if you can replace Supergirl with Superman in your story and it still works? You've failed."

    CBR: Marvel really doesn't have an equivalent character to Kara, nor do they have a solo female series with a 60-odd year history behind her the way Supergirl does.


    WHOA! You mean to tell me that there were ten more years of Supergirl that we all didn't know about? :P ;)

    The only Marvel character that I could think of that is closest to being the equivalent to Supergirl is She-Hulk.

    GENE

    ReplyDelete
  5. Lois is a hard-charging, dynamic, and always in-control personality, and those types often violate boundaries without meaning to even with the people they're closest with (yes, I that's a bit of self-commentary.) No matter how close they may have become I can imagine any number of ways that Lois could over-step, mostly dealing with her need to be in control of all situations. We don't know that it comes from asking for help, it could very well come from making commitments for Kara without asking to setting 'Linda' up on a blind date like she recently did with Jimmy Olsen. All relationships have bumps, if they develop organically from the characters and the story I'll enjoy it. I can just hear a conversation like "Kara, we have an investigation at Stanhope college to do. I've enrolled you for this term, here's your class schedule." "You did WHAT?"

    Silver Age Supergirl? Yes, that was a strange question, she handled it well. I could almost hear the "Say whaaa??" in the first three sentences of her response.

    I don't think the Loeb Kara is coming back - SHE was the anomaly in 50 years of Supergirl stories, not the Supergirl as currently portrayed.

    Martin, I totally agree. While I'm with anon about missing David's Linda Danvers, I don't miss the obnoxious, selfish narcissist Kara from the first two years. She's grown into a character that can be admired from one that was difficult to even like.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Well is Superman is the "King" of the Red-S Franchise, then it is logical for Lois to assume that she is it's Queen by right of Marriage to Kal El. I can see how Kara Zor El would resent this given her onetime status as a "Princess" (if a hard pressed one) on New Krypton. Queens can be bossy and presumptuous, Supergirl could easily see some parallels between Lois and Kara's own late overbearing mother.
    Just some thoughts...

    John Feer

    ReplyDelete
  7. Martin, I politely disagree. I think she has become much less comfident, with too much focus on being in Superman's shadow. The earlier Supergirl was headstrong and overconfident, which I appeciate more. Under Puckett, Palmiotti, and the first Gates issue, there were too many dumb blond moments.

    Also, I disagree with obnoxious. I like her betted speaking her mind. Now, the books about self doubt, restraint, and ridding her of hormones and sex appeal. She's just been kind of boring, and that's the anomaly, because that hadn't been the case with her since the 50's and 60's.

    ReplyDelete
  8. Also, I said Loeb's Supergirl so let's not conflate everthing you disliked about the pre Gates issues with Loeb. I've disliked some of Kelly and pretty much everything since.

    I hope you're correct about her being confident again, but I didn't see much of that in 20-38. Instead, she spent most of her time crying, messing up, being disrespected by others, apologizing when she should have been fighting back, needing Superman, etc. I flat out hated her in those issues, after loving her in the 80's to the early issues of this series.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Lois unconsciously resentful of Supergirl, since "Superman's Girlfriend" went from headlining in her own comic to being a back up feature in "The Daring New Adventures of Supergirl". Lets face it, Kara cramps Lois' style big time.

    :D

    John Feer

    ReplyDelete
  10. All relationships have bumps, if they develop organically from the characters and the story I'll enjoy it. I can just hear a conversation like "Kara, we have an investigation at Stanhope college to do. I've enrolled you for this term, here's your class schedule." "You did WHAT?"

    Thanks for the post.

    Now that makes sense. I pictured the encounter as Lois just asking for help. But going an extra step as you suggest would definitely lead to the sort of bristling DeConnick talks about.

    ReplyDelete
  11. The Kara you liked, Anon, seemed to me obnoxious, confused ... I like that she's grown into a confident young hero, not so quick to charge into situations.

    I'm with you Mart. Not that I want to open up the Loeb/Kelly vs Gates argument again.

    But #19 was almost 3 years ago. Time to realize that direction is a thing of the past.

    ReplyDelete
  12. It was an interesting interview. I particularly enjoyed this line from DeConnick:

    "I'm oversimplifying, clearly -- but if you can replace Supergirl with Superman in your story and it still works? You've failed."


    I liked that line as well. And she is exactly right.

    ReplyDelete
  13. I hope you're correct about her being confident again, but I didn't see much of that in 20-38. Instead, she spent most of her time crying, messing up, being disrespected by others, apologizing when she should have been fighting back, needing Superman, etc.

    The thing is throughout the whole Gates run she becomes more mature, more heroic, more composed. She still has an edge but is doing the right thing.

    I think you quit to early if you stopped at #38. And you should definitely pick up the current arc if Gates wasn't your cup of tea.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Queens can be bossy and presumptuous, Supergirl could easily see some parallels between Lois and Kara's own late overbearing mother.

    Interesting thought John. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Where is Supergirl supporting cast in all of this. I haven't seen or heard anything about them since these new creative teams have taken over.

    I'm this close to dropping this book. Which is a shame because this use to be my favorite comic.

    ReplyDelete