In 2004, DC comics came out with a series called Solo which lasted 12 issues. Each issue showcased a creator who was allowed to use the pages in any way they wished. Filled with autobiographical stories, super-hero stories 'out of continuity', or simply stories, it was a nice format and allowed fans to get a closer look at some great artists. The first issue showcased superstar Tim Sale.
Within this issue is an 8 page Supergirl story written by Diane Schutz. I don't know much of Schutz. Her bio on http://www.comicbookdb.com/ states she is a senior editor at Dark Horse as well as professor of comic books at Portland Community College. Her resume of Dark Horse editing jobs is impressive including heavyweights like Grendel, Sin City, and American Splendor just to name a few.
As a Supergirl fan, I cannot tell you how great this short story is. It is emotionally powerful. The art perfectly captures the words. It picks up a plot thread left dangling from the pre-Crisis DCU. And it clearly shows a love of the Supergirl character.
The story revolves around Linda (Supergirl) Danvers on again/off again relationship with Dick Malverne. Dick started out as an inquisitive boy at the Midvale orphanage with Linda who was always trying to prove she had super-powers. Later they both get adopted, attend Stanhope University together, and date. In the last issue of Supergirl Vol.2 (1982), the last panels, drawn by legend Carmine Infantino, show Dick re-entering Linda's life suddenly.
The comic was cancelled and a proposed Superboy/Supergirl comic never came to fruition. Supergirl was seen sparingly thereafter and was killed in Crisis #7.
The Schutz/Sale story picks up right where that issue left off.
Similar panels, aren't they. The first couple of pages of this story recap the Malverne/Danvers relationship, replaying actual scenes from Supergirl continuity ... the first time he thought Linda was Supergirl, seeing him for the first time since they were adopted - a chance meeting on a beach, a date at a carnival ... all from prior issues but re-imagined briefly here. It is such a nice homage to what had come before. Clearly, Schutz and Sale have a love of the character. Here is a snippet of the beach scene.
Sadly, Dick confesses that he sought out Linda to tell her that he is dying of cancer. He also tells her that he has always known she was Supergirl. He implores her to be strong ... to find her inner strength. He implores her to be the hero she can be.
He succumbs to the cancer and passes on.
The last panel shows a crest-fallen Linda sipping wine in her bunny slippers, stroking Streaky, as she realizes that despite her invulnerability her heart can still be broken ... that her powers cannot save everyone.
The words here are wonderful.
What's is not to love here? Sale's art is solid throughout. He really does a nice Supergirl.
The writer clearly had a solid understanding and knowledge of Supergirl's history. And we see a growing Supergirl, still with some of the innocence of the Silver Age ... I mean Streaky and bunny slippers! Absolutely perfect! Absolutely spectacular! If you are a Supergirl fan, I highly recommend you find this comic.
Overall grade: A+
Great looking blog. I'm a big Supergirl fan as well, so its nice to see Kara and Linda, etc. etc. get their due.
ReplyDeleteKeep up the good work!
Thanks so much for the compliment.
ReplyDeleteYou run such a great blog that it really means a lot.
I will try to keep up the good work, and promise to review one of Aparo's Batman/Supergirl Brave and Bold issues soon.
Again, great Supergirl blog!
ReplyDelete"Solo #1" is a beautiful (if bittersweet) coda for the second Supergirl series, FINALLY tying up a loose end that dangled for 20 years! And the fate of poor Dick Malverne sadly echoed what happened to his post-Crisis incarnation in Peter David's series. I also highly recommend it.
"Solo #1" is a beautiful (if bittersweet) coda for the second Supergirl series, FINALLY tying up a loose end that dangled for 20 years! And the fate of poor Dick Malverne sadly echoed what happened to his post-Crisis incarnation in Peter David's series. I also highly recommend it.
ReplyDeleteIt was great to see this story told in such a wonderful way. I recommend this issue all the time.
Just wondering...
ReplyDeleteWhere have the rest of the cast members of Peter David's Supergirl gone?
I only say Wally pop up in the Supergirl in the 8th Grade series.
What about Buzz, Cutter, Linda's Parents and Andy?
-ealperin
I’ve just reread this because it came up on Prof Alan’s Reading Journal. I cried all over again.
ReplyDeleteIf I’ve forgotten, I apologise, but in the absence of a Sixty Years of Supergirl collection, have you compiled your fantasy version? This tale would get straight in there, along with Crisis on I finite Earths #7, the Deadman story, the DCCP Mongul story, Adventure Comics, Action Comics #286... ach, you can come up with less obvious entries (OK, #408 is likely no one else’s favourite, but it’s a good spooky example of Sekowsky Kara).
Over to you!
I am afraid to read the review, done one month into my blogging career.
ReplyDeleteI don't think my style has changed much but I am fearful.
Yes, I should do some sort of compilation of my faves. Would you want just Kara Zor-El stories? Or could some Matrix make their way in?
The post is great, have a read!
ReplyDeleteYour call on the choices, but the other DC books cover everything - the Superboy one apparently has the horrendous Superboy Prime Story from Infinite Crisis #6. His origin is in there, but a Superboy villain shouldn’t be in a ‘Celebration’... so no dark Karas, eh? Unless it’s the original Satan Girl!
Plus, we do need some Gates/Igle and the best of PAD.
And remember to pick a cover artist. Go wild.